1. An apple floats on water.
2. The apple floats on water.
3. Apples float on water.
--------------------------------
Are they all in generic use?
Are they all mean #4?
Does 'the apple' in #2 mean 'the specific apple'?
4. Any apple floats on water.
2 is not generic since it's talking about a specific apple
All are grammatically correct and generally in use, depending on the context.
And yes, in 2 it’s referring to a specific apple.
1. "An apple floats on water" - This sentence is in generic use. It implies that any apple, without specifying a particular apple, will float on water. It is a general statement about the behavior of apples in water.
2. "The apple floats on water" - This sentence is not in generic use. "The" indicates a specific apple, referring to a particular apple that has been previously mentioned or is known in the context. It implies that this specific apple, which has been established or is under discussion, is floating on water.
3. "Apples float on water" - This sentence is in generic use. It is similar to sentence 1 and implies that all apples, as a group, will float on water. Like sentence 1, it is a general statement about the behavior of apples in water.
4. "Any apple floats on water" - This sentence is also in generic use. It implies that regardless of the specific apple in question, whether known or not, any apple will float on water. It is a general statement similar to sentences 1 and 3, emphasizing the behavior of apples as a whole rather than a specific apple.