Can some please help. Many judes in the criminal court system are not only overworked. but must cntend with the worst society. How does the role and responsibility of a judge differ in a rel-life courtroom as opposed to the mistiqe portrayed in the movies or on television?

Please note that we don't do students' homework for them. Be sure to go back into your textbook or use a good search engine. http://hanlib.sou.edu/searchtools/

Once YOU have come up with attempted answers to YOUR questions, please re-post and let us know what you think. Then someone here will be happy to comment on your thinking.

=)

D, did you find out anything yet? If you don't know what to search for, try searching for any of the following at http://www.google.com -- and watch your spelling!

judges overworked reasons

compare judges real television
movies

types judges

judge job description


And any other combinations you can think of.

In real-life courtrooms, the role and responsibilities of judges differ significantly from how they are portrayed in movies or on television. To understand these differences, let's break it down:

1. Judicial Role:
- Real-Life Courtroom: Judges are responsible for ensuring fair and impartial administration of justice. They act as neutral arbiters who interpret and apply the law.
- Movie/TV Portrayal: Judges are often depicted as active participants who engage in dramatic confrontations, making emotional or biased decisions to further the storyline.

2. Decision-Making Process:
- Real-Life Courtroom: Judges base their decisions on legal principles, statutes, precedents, and evidence presented by both sides during the trial. They must follow established laws and regulations.
- Movie/TV Portrayal: Judges may make spontaneous, unorthodox decisions based on personal biases or emotions, often disregarding legal procedures and standards.

3. Courtroom Procedures:
- Real-Life Courtroom: Judges ensure that court proceedings adhere to legal protocols. They manage the courtroom, maintain order, and rule on objections raised by the legal parties. They ensure due process and a fair trial for all.
- Movie/TV Portrayal: Judges frequently become directly involved in the proceedings, interrogating witnesses, intervening in arguments, and influencing the outcomes dramatically.

4. Pre-Trial Activities:
- Real-Life Courtroom: Judges play an active role in managing pre-trial activities, including overseeing bail hearings, evaluating motions, setting trial dates, and managing negotiations between parties where appropriate.
- Movie/TV Portrayal: Pre-trial activities are often glossed over or exaggerated for dramatic effect, minimizing the judge's involvement in these crucial stages.

5. Caseload Management:
- Real-Life Courtroom: Judges handle an extensive caseload and are required to manage their time efficiently by conducting research, reviewing legal documents, and making informed decisions within allocated timeframes.
- Movie/TV Portrayal: Caseload management is rarely portrayed, and judges may give the impression of being solely dedicated to the specific case depicted in the story.

Overall, it's important to remember that real-life judges operate within a legal framework, relying on legal expertise and impartiality to make decisions. While movies and television often dramatize their roles for entertainment purposes, the actual responsibility of a judge is to uphold the law and ensure justice is served.