17. Some people believe that feelings should be nurtured and cherished, while others argue that feelings should be curbed and kept under control. Indicate one poem that demonstrates the desire to restrain emotion and one poem that demonstrates the desire to cherish emotion. Give a brief reason for your choices.

Question

17. Some people believe that feelings should be nurtured and cherished, while others argue that feelings should be curbed and kept under control. Indicate one poem that demonstrates the desire to restrain emotion and one poem that demonstrates the desire to cherish emotion. Give a brief reason for your choices.

So I can only choose from these poems:
Mother to Son by Langston Hughes
Miss Rosie by Lucille Clifton
Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening by Robert Frost
George Gray by Edgar Lee Masters.

I am unsure of how to figure out which poems cherish emotion and which restrain emotion. I was thinking that the poem George Gray restrains emotions since it talks about a guy who shut everything out.

Answer 1

I agree with you about "George Gray."

If you're going to choose among the other three for the "cherish emotion" example, make sure you read all of them -- OUT LOUD to someone! -- and then decide.

Answer 2

Also pay attention to what emotions are described in each poem. In "Mother to Son", are ANY emotions mentioned or implied? Are they in a positive or negative way? Are any human feelings expressed?

Answer 3

To determine which poems cherish or restrain emotion, it's important to closely analyze the messages and themes present in each poem. Let's examine the given choices:

1. "Mother to Son" by Langston Hughes: This poem uses the metaphor of a mother speaking to her son, conveying the struggles and hardships she has faced. The poem emphasizes the importance of perseverance and determination despite obstacles. This poem can be seen as cherishing emotion, as it encourages acknowledging and expressing one's feelings to overcome challenges.

2. "Miss Rosie" by Lucille Clifton: This poem explores the life of an elderly woman named Rosie and her experiences. It reflects on her past as a vibrant and beautiful woman, contrasting with her current state. While the poem acknowledges the difficulties and challenges faced by Rosie, it also addresses the resilience and strength that exists within her. This poem can be interpreted as cherishing the emotions and memories associated with aging and reflecting on one's life.

3. "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening" by Robert Frost: This poem describes a person stopping by a remote snowy wood and contemplating its beauty and serenity. It signifies a moment of escape from the world's obligations and responsibilities. While it acknowledges the allure of staying in the peaceful environment, the poem ultimately emphasizes the importance of duty and keeping emotions restrained. Therefore, it can be considered an example of restraining emotion.

4. "George Gray" by Edgar Lee Masters: This poem delves into the introspective thoughts and emotions of George Gray, who contemplates his unfulfilled ambitions and the fear of taking risks in life. The poem expresses a desire to shut out emotions and experiences, focusing on living a subdued and restricted life. Thus, this poem can be regarded as restraining emotion.

Based on this analysis, your initial intuition about "George Gray" restraining emotions is correct. As for a poem that demonstrates the desire to cherish emotions, "Mother to Son" can be a suitable choice.