Each of the underlined premises can be taken as an unacceptable premise in an argument. In each case, identify the condition of premise unacceptability
Premise: Most people dislike quitters
Conclusion: Therefore, I shouldn’t quit smoking
I`m having trouble with this question, if someone could help it would be much appreciated, thanks
The word "quitters" is ambiguous, so the premise is unacceptable.
http://faculty.unlv.edu/ledwig/chapterfive.html
To identify the condition of premise unacceptability in the given argument, we need to examine the underlying assumptions and potential flaws in each premise.
Premise: Most people dislike quitters
Condition of premise unacceptability: This premise might be considered unacceptable if it is based on unfounded generalizations or lacks reliable evidence. Without specific data or research supporting the claim that "most people dislike quitters," the premise becomes weak and subjective. Additionally, even if it were true that most people dislike quitters, it doesn't necessarily follow that an individual should not quit smoking based solely on others' opinions.
Conclusion: Therefore, I shouldn’t quit smoking
Condition of premise unacceptability: The conclusion may be seen as unacceptable if it relies solely on the premise being true without considering other relevant factors. Quitting smoking is a personal decision that depends on various factors such as health, personal preferences, and individual circumstances. Relying solely on the premise that "most people dislike quitters" to justify not quitting smoking overlooks the importance of one's own health and well-being.
In summary, the condition of premise unacceptability in this argument lies in the potential lack of evidential support for the claim that most people dislike quitters, as well as the oversimplification of the decision to quit smoking based on societal opinions rather than individual considerations.