1. Explain the difference between a mystery and a legend.
2. Create a list of at least five (5) of these proven and unproven beliefs about your chosen event.
3. Explain why each of the items in the list are proven or unproven.
1. A mystery is something that remains unexplained whereas a legend is a story that has been handed down by tradition from earlier
generations and is accepted as historical.
2. My five proven and unproven beliefs concerning Atlantis are: 1. Atlantis is an island that is set in the Atlantic Ocean. 2. There are many theories as to the exact location and destiny of Atlantis. 3. The question on whether Atlantis exists has been debated for many years. 4. The legend of Atlantis’s existence began with Plato who mentioned it in one of his writings. From the time of 1600s to now the question as to Atlantis and its existence has been debated. 5. The lost city of Atlantis has been depicted in many movies and books.
3. One proven belief that Atlantis is a legend comes when Plato mentions it. Plato in “Timaeus” says that Atlantis was larger than Asia Minor and Libya, and was a once-ideal state that became corrupt and militaristic and used its great power to attempt to conquer the world. It was destroyed by earthquakes and sank into the Atlantic Ocean. Atlantis is proven to be a mystery because the idea of an advanced civilization where learning and scientific research were encouraged appealed to Western rationalists who tried to identify the lost land with America and the Canary Islands. Atlantis is proven to be a legend when Atlantis’s rediscovery occurs in Jules Verne’s 20,000 Leagues Under The Sea (1870), where science, in the shape of a submarine, fulfills its promise of answers to questions such as the one regarding Atlantis’s existence. Atlantis is a proven mystery as there are many theories as to the exact location and destiny of Atlantis. Yet the question has been debated by such notable writers as Montaigne and Voltaire dating back to as early as the 1600’s. The delightfully comic and touching novel “Masters of Atlantis” by Charles Portis proves Atlantis is a legend where he centers on an oddball character who dedicates his life to the preservation of the lore and wisdom of lost Atlantis. Atlantis: The Lost Empire is a movie that came out in 2001 by Walt Disney where a young man, along with a crew, relies on a book to guide them to the lost city of Atlantis. Other movies include Atlantis, the Lost Continent (1961), Atlantis: Milo’s Return (2003), and The Atlantis Interceptors (1983). These all reference Atlantis yet the question of its existence still lingers on today.
No, I am not expecting anyone to do the work for me. I have answered three questions and would like to get the opinion as to whether I am doing it correctly.
1. A mystery is something that remains unexplained whereas a legend is a story that has been handed down by tradition from earlier generations and is accepted as historical.
So ... legends can still be mysteries, right? Unexplained, but nevertheless accepted as "historical"? Your teacher may want clarification about that.
What you wrote for 2 all sound fine.
For 3, remember that Greeks and others sometimes use/used fictional places to illustrate the points they are trying to make. With that in mind, re-read what you wrote for 3, and repost if you change your mind or your phrasing and want it re-checked.
1. Ah, the difference between a mystery and a legend. It's like trying to tell the difference between a magician and a clown. One baffles you with tricks while the other just bumbles around making you laugh. A mystery, my friend, is like a magician's trick. It's something that remains unexplained, keeping us all wondering and scratching our heads. On the other hand, a legend is like a clown's hilarious performance. It's a story that has been passed down through generations, accepted as historical, but with a touch of exaggeration and imagination. So, while a mystery leaves us puzzled, a legend leaves us entertained and a little bit wiser, or at least believing in talking animals and giants.
2. Alright, buckle up for some mind-boggling beliefs about Atlantis!
1. Atlantis is an island surrounded by the mighty Atlantic Ocean. Proven by its name, right?
2. The exact location and destiny of Atlantis have triggered countless theories. Unproven because no one has found it yet. Maybe it's hiding behind a curtain or chilling with the Loch Ness Monster.
3. People have been arguing about Atlantis's existence for ages. It's like the world's longest debate club meeting.
4. Atlantis made its grand entrance into our collective imaginations thanks to Plato and his writings. Proven because Plato said so. Who are we to argue with a Greek philosopher?
5. Atlantis has been the star of many movies and books, reminding us that it may be lost, but it's not forgotten. Proven by Hollywood's obsession with sinking ancient civilizations.
3. Let's dive into the depths of proven and unproven beliefs about Atlantis. Plato's mention in "Timaeus" gives Atlantis a touch of legitimacy, but until we find it sitting pretty in the Atlantic, it remains a mysterious tale. Theories about Atlantis's location and destiny have been brewing for centuries, but without concrete evidence, they stay in the realm of speculation. The endless debates about Atlantis's existence prove that it's a mystery that keeps us all guessing.
On the other side of the coin, legends of Atlantis have taken on a life of their own. Jules Verne's "20,000 Leagues Under the Sea" and movies like Disney's "Atlantis: The Lost Empire" add fuel to the legend's fire, providing entertainment and imagination. Charles Portis's novel "Masters of Atlantis" follows an eccentric character dedicated to preserving the lore and wisdom of the lost city, proving that legends can be as captivating as a clown juggling rubber chickens.
So, my friend, while Atlantis may be a beacon of curiosity and wonder, it remains both a mysterious enigma and a legendary tale that tickles our imagination. How's that for a mind-boggling balancing act?
1. The difference between a mystery and a legend is that a mystery is something that remains unexplained and lacks clear evidence or answers, while a legend is a story that has been passed down through generations and is accepted as historical, even if it may be embellished or fictionalized.
2. Here are five proven and unproven beliefs about the event of Atlantis:
Proven beliefs:
1. Atlantis is an island set in the Atlantic Ocean.
2. The question of the exact location and fate of Atlantis has been the subject of numerous theories and debates.
3. The legend of Atlantis's existence originates from Plato's writings, specifically his mention of it in "Timaeus."
Unproven beliefs:
4. The existence of Atlantis has been debated for centuries, with no conclusive evidence or consensus reached.
5. Atlantis has been depicted in various movies and books, such as Disney's "Atlantis: The Lost Empire" and Jules Verne's "20,000 Leagues Under The Sea."
3. The items in the list can be categorized as proven or unproven based on the available evidence:
- The first three beliefs are considered proven because they are supported by historical records, specifically Plato's mention of Atlantis in his writings.
- The fourth belief is unproven because it acknowledges the ongoing debate and lack of evidence surrounding the existence of Atlantis. Despite extensive theorizing and speculation, no concrete proof has been discovered.
- The fifth belief is also unproven since it refers to fictional depictions of Atlantis in movies and books. While these works may draw inspiration from the legend, they do not provide factual evidence for Atlantis's existence.
In summary, the proven beliefs are supported by historical sources, while the unproven beliefs highlight the ongoing uncertainty and speculation surrounding Atlantis.
You're expecting someone to do all this work for you?
Or do you have questions about the assignments?