read this quotation ¨of representation in congress is to be determined by the number of people who live in each state should slaves be counted?¨
At the constitutional convention how would someone form a southern state most likely respond?
a) yes, they love in our state, and they should be counted**
b) yes, they are equal to white people and should be counted,**
c) no, slaves were not born in the states and should not be counted.
d) no, slaves are not equal to white people and should not be counted.
please help i am between A and B.
One of those -- A or B -- is correct.
Think about the southerner's point of view.
I think it is a am i correct? Ms. Sue?
A is correct -- if you mean they LIVE in your state.
thank you very much! :)
You are very welcome.
To answer this question, it is essential to understand the context and historical background of the constitutional convention. The issue of counting slaves for representation in Congress was a significant debate during that time. Here's how you can arrive at the correct answer:
1. Read the quotation: "Of representation in congress is to be determined by the number of people who live in each state, should slaves be counted?"
2. Identify the perspective of a southern state: In this scenario, consider the historical context of the southern states, which heavily relied on slavery as an economic and social institution.
3. Analyze Response A: The response, "Yes, they live in our state, and they should be counted," recognizes that slaves are part of the population and should contribute to the state's representation. This response aligns with the interests of southern states as they desired to have a higher population count for increased representation in Congress.
4. Evaluate Response B: The response, "Yes, they are equal to white people and should be counted," suggests that slaves should be counted because they are equal to white people. While this response appears to be fair and just, it does not fully align with the historical reality of slavery in America. Slavery viewed enslaved individuals as property and denied them the rights and privileges afforded to white people.
Based on historical context and the interests of southern states during the constitutional convention, the most likely response would be A) "Yes, they live in our state, and they should be counted."