Act 1 Scene 1 .. Romeo & Juliet
I don't know the answer to two of my questions for Romeo and Juliet the first one . . .
Although Rome and Juliet is a tragedy, much of the play is quite comic. Outline briefly the comic elements in this scene. To whatextent is romeos infatuation for Rosaline Comic?
Is Romeo in love with Rosaline or is it infatuation? What is the diffrence? If you had a friend in a similar situation to Romeo's, what advice would you give that person?
To answer the first question look at the words "bawdy" and "punning"...
http://www.sparknotes.com/shakespeare/romeojuliet/section2.rhtml
You will be able to find the answer to the second question here also.
Romeo's infatuation for Rosaline is comic because it is a shallow, immature love that is not based on any real understanding of Rosaline's character.
If you had a friend in a similar situation to Romeo's, you would advise them to take the time to get to know the person they are interested in, rather than just being infatuated with them. You would also advise them to think carefully about the consequences of their actions, as Romeo's impulsive behavior leads to tragedy in the play.
To answer your first question about the comic elements in Act 1 Scene 1 of Romeo and Juliet, you can refer to the specific words "bawdy" and "punning" mentioned in the link you provided. These words indicate that there is humor in the scene. Bawdy refers to something that is indecent or lewd, and punning involves wordplay with double meanings. By exploring the dialogue and actions of the characters in this scene, you can identify instances of comedic elements.
As for the second question about Romeo's feelings for Rosaline, you can also find the answer in the same link. Romeo's infatuation for Rosaline is indeed considered comic because it is unrealistic and exaggerated. Infatuation is often characterized by a superficial attraction based on physical appearance or idealized qualities, and it tends to be short-lived. In this case, Romeo's infatuation for Rosaline is seen as comic because he is overly dramatic and obsessed with an unattainable love.
The difference between being in love and being infatuated lies in the depth and maturity of the emotions. Love is typically characterized by a deep emotional connection, care, and commitment towards someone, whereas infatuation is more based on intense passion, idealization, and often lacks a sense of reality. Love tends to be long-lasting and stable, while infatuation is usually temporary and less substantial.
If you had a friend in a similar situation to Romeo's infatuation for Rosaline, it would be wise to advise them to take some time to reflect on their feelings and assess if it is a genuine connection or just a passing infatuation. Encourage your friend to focus on getting to know the person better on a deeper level to truly understand their compatibility. It would also be important to remind them to maintain a sense of realism in their expectations and avoid becoming overly dramatic or consumed by their feelings. Ultimately, it is crucial to support your friend in making thoughtful decisions based on both their emotional and rational considerations.
In Act 1, Scene 1 of Romeo and Juliet, there are indeed comic elements present. These elements primarily revolve around the banter and wordplay among the characters. Mercutio, in particular, brings in a lot of humor with his quick wit and use of bawdy language. The scene involves several instances of punning, where characters make play on words, which adds a light-hearted tone to the overall tragic story.
Regarding Romeo's infatuation for Rosaline, it can be considered somewhat comic in nature. His exaggerated expression of love and melancholy over a woman who has not returned his affections showcases a certain level of emotional immaturity and absurdity. This infatuation is portrayed comically as Romeo pines over Rosaline's unattainable beauty and becomes overly sentimental.
The difference between love and infatuation lies in their depth and lasting nature. Love involves a deep emotional connection, understanding, and commitment, whereas infatuation is usually characterized by intense passion and attraction that is often short-lived and based on idealized perceptions. In Romeo's case, it can be argued that his feelings for Rosaline are infatuation, as he is captivated by her beauty without truly knowing her or having a deeper emotional connection.
If advising a friend in a similar situation to Romeo's, I would suggest taking a step back and evaluating their feelings more rationally. It's essential to give oneself time to understand whether their emotions are genuine and based on a solid foundation or if they are merely infatuated with an idealized image of the person. Encouraging self-reflection, taking time to get to know the person better, and considering the possibilities of a deeper emotional connection would be prudent advice in such a scenario.