Which of the following techniques would be best used to present constructive feedback on a draft of an

essay to a peer?
A. Rewrite sections for your peer
B. Only write notes on the things you like about it
C. Point out the negative aspects so your peer can improve
D. Concentrate on content and the message of the paper

my answer is d.

I agree.

You have chosen option D, which is to concentrate on the content and the message of the paper. This is indeed a good approach when providing constructive feedback on a draft of an essay to a peer.

To explain how to arrive at this answer, let's break down the options:

Option A: Rewrite sections for your peer
While it may be tempting to rewrite sections for your peer, this approach does not empower them to improve their own writing skills. It's important for the peer to be actively involved in the revision process.

Option B: Only write notes on the things you like about it
While it is important to highlight positive aspects of the draft, focusing solely on the positives might not offer the peer the opportunity to identify areas for improvement. Constructive feedback should guide the peer towards enhancing their writing.

Option C: Point out the negative aspects so your peer can improve
This option seems close to being the correct answer as it mentions the importance of pointing out negative aspects for improvement. However, it is often more helpful to provide a balanced perspective by addressing both strengths and weaknesses.

Option D: Concentrate on content and the message of the paper
This option is the best choice as it emphasizes the importance of focusing on the main ideas, arguments, and overall message of the essay. Providing feedback on content allows the peer to make substantial revisions, resulting in a stronger final draft.

In summary, while it's important to be considerate and highlight positive aspects when giving feedback, the most effective approach is to concentrate on the content and message of the draft. By doing so, you will guide your peer to make necessary improvements and communicate their ideas more effectively.