15. Which of the following is not an example of an ethical dilemma a defense
attorney may face?
A) the prosecutor's winning record.
B) client perjury.
C) defense receipt of physical evidence.
D) a confession in confidence.
I think it is A ? Would that be correct?
To determine which of the options is not an example of an ethical dilemma a defense attorney may face, we need to understand what an ethical dilemma is in the context of a defense attorney's role.
An ethical dilemma refers to a situation where a professional is faced with conflicting moral responsibilities or obligations. Defense attorneys often encounter ethical dilemmas as they balance their duty to represent their clients diligently and ethically while upholding the integrity of the legal system.
Let's analyze each of the options to determine which one is not an example of an ethical dilemma a defense attorney may face:
A) The prosecutor's winning record: This can potentially create an ethical dilemma for a defense attorney if they believe the prosecutor's record is the result of unethical tactics or manipulation of evidence. It can raise concerns about a fair trial or due process. Therefore, option A can be an example of an ethical dilemma for a defense attorney.
B) Client perjury: When a defense attorney becomes aware of their client committing perjury (lying under oath), an ethical dilemma arises. Defense attorneys have an obligation to act with honesty and integrity in the legal process, and knowingly allowing perjury can lead to ethical complications. Thus, option B can also be an example of an ethical dilemma.
C) Defense receipt of physical evidence: The defense attorney receiving physical evidence is not an example of an ethical dilemma in itself. It is a standard part of the legal process for the defense to gather evidence and build a strong defense. Therefore, option C is less likely to be an example of an ethical dilemma for a defense attorney.
D) A confession in confidence: This option presents an ethical dilemma for defense attorneys. If a client confesses to a crime in confidence, the attorney may face the dilemma of whether to use that information in court or maintain the duty of confidentiality and not present the confession. This situation involves a conflict between the attorney's legal duty to their client and their ethical obligations to the court, the truth, and the legal profession. Therefore, option D can also be an example of an ethical dilemma.
In conclusion, option C, defense receipt of physical evidence, is the least likely to be an example of an ethical dilemma a defense attorney may face.