why not #1?

"Island Boy" by Barbra Cooney, is a
good choice for literature curriculum
in the primary grades because it:

1. is useful in all areas of development
2. is easily understood by students
3. provides beautiful illustrations
4. includes a setting unfamiliar to
most children
I know the setting of the story is on
an island. And I know the correct answer is 1 or 4. Can you give input,
please?

I would think that 4 would be the better of those two.

I say #1. Just Go for it! It's the most logical...

To determine the correct answer between option 1 and option 4, let's analyze each option.

Option 1 states that "Island Boy" by Barbra Cooney is useful in all areas of development. This means that the book has educational value across various aspects, such as cognitive, social, emotional, and physical development. However, without further information about the content of the book, it is difficult to assess whether it fulfills this claim.

Option 4 states that the book includes a setting unfamiliar to most children. This implies that the story takes place in a unique location, such as an island, which may captivate children's interest and expand their knowledge about different environments.

Given the information you provided that the setting of the story is on an island, it seems that option 4 aligns with this detail. The fact that the setting is unfamiliar to most children can make it more appealing and engaging, offering them a new cultural or geographical perspective.

Although option 1 could be a valid reason to include the book in a literature curriculum, the specific detail about the setting being unfamiliar points towards option 4 as a more accurate choice. However, it's important to note that the answer ultimately depends on the specific criteria and goals of the literature curriculum in question.

Therefore, in this case, option 4 is the better choice based on the given information.