In "A Cub Pilot" the author says: "Judgement is a matter of brains, and a man must start with a good stock of that article, or he will never succeed as a pilot." Which of the following best restates the author's idea?

A: Riverboat pilots must have good judgement.

B: Success as a pilot depends only on judgement.

C: Good judgement is more important to a pilot than good brains.

D: Pilots must have stock in the riverboat company.

Well -- it's not D.

Which of the other three do you think are right?

I think that the answer is A. what would you guess

Yes, it's A.

Thank you!

You're welcome.

To determine the best restatement of the author's idea, we need to consider what the author is actually saying. According to the author, judgment is a crucial quality for a pilot, and having a good stock of brains is essential for success in this occupation. Therefore, the best restatement of the author's idea would be:

A: Riverboat pilots must have good judgment.

Explanation to arrive at the answer:
We can deduce this answer choice by analyzing the original quote and breaking it down: "Judgment is a matter of brains, and a man must start with a good stock of that article, or he will never succeed as a pilot." From this, we can infer that good judgment is important for pilots. Answer choice A correctly restates this idea by saying "Riverboat pilots must have good judgment."