Red Jacket and Tecumseh in their respective speeches (again, as translated and transcribed), make frequent reference to “brothers” and brotherhood. Why such emphasis, at that historical moment, upon fraternity and unity? CAN SOMEONE CHECK MY ANSWER TO SEE IF I ANSWER THE QUESTION RIGHT
Introduction
Red Jacket and Tecumseh in their respective speeches make frequent reference to “brothers” and brotherhood. They emphasized this since at this time there was American revolutionary war and both Red Jacket and Tecumseh were Native Americans and they were to be forced to leave the land.
The two were leaders in their respective clans and thus they led the campaign of negotiating with the American government to stop the war and save the lives of their people. They argued that they were one family and thus should live in harmony as brothers with the indigenous Americans. In their speeches they stressed on togetherness and the end of the American revolutionary war.
Both Red Jacket and Tecumseh supported the British government in their quest to control America. That made it had to convince the indigenous Americans on observance of brotherhood and harmony among themselves. Red Jacket was a renowned orator and he used his works to spread messages of brotherhood and harmony between the Native American and the indigenous American.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Red Jacket and Tecumseh emphasized on fraternity and unity of the different races since they knew that they were in foreign land and thus were aliens. They wanted the indigenous Americas to accept and live with them. The revolutionary war made the American to gain their independence from the hands of the British rule.
Your answer provides a good understanding of why Red Jacket and Tecumseh emphasized brotherhood and unity in their speeches. However, I would like to provide some additional insights to help you further refine and strengthen your answer.
Firstly, the emphasis on brotherhood and unity during that historical moment was rooted in the shared experience of oppression and displacement faced by Native American tribes due to American expansionism and territorial encroachment. Native tribes were being forcibly removed from their ancestral lands, leading to the fragmentation of their communities and way of life.
Red Jacket and Tecumseh recognized that in order to resist and overcome the encroachment on their land and rights, they needed a united front. By cultivating a sense of brotherhood and unity among their own people, they aimed to create a strong collective identity and foster a sense of solidarity against the common enemy – the American government and its policies.
Furthermore, referring to one another as "brothers" and emphasizing this concept of brotherhood served to highlight the interconnectedness and mutual responsibility that existed among Native American tribes. It was a way to remind their people of the importance of standing together and supporting one another in the face of adversity.
Additionally, the use of the term "brothers" and the emphasis on fraternity also had rhetorical and persuasive power. It appealed to the values and ideals of the American Revolutionary era, which championed notions of equality, freedom, and brotherhood among all citizens. By framing their cause in these terms, Red Jacket and Tecumseh sought to appeal to the principles on which the new American nation was founded, hoping to garner sympathy and support from non-Native American audiences.
So, in summary, the emphasis on brotherhood and unity in the speeches of Red Jacket and Tecumseh during that historical moment was driven by the need for collective resistance against American expansionism, the desire to maintain cultural identity and solidarity within Native American tribes, and the strategic use of rhetoric to gain support both within and outside of their communities.
Your answer is partly correct, but there are a few points that can be clarified and expanded upon.
During the historical moment in which Red Jacket and Tecumseh gave their speeches, there were several factors that contributed to the emphasis on fraternity and unity.
Firstly, both Red Jacket and Tecumseh were leaders of Native American tribes during a time when American expansionism was threatening their way of life and the lands they occupied. They saw the need to unite their respective tribes and create a sense of brotherhood in order to resist the encroachment of settlers.
Secondly, the American Revolutionary War had recently ended, and the United States was newly formed. Red Jacket and Tecumseh recognized that, in this changing political landscape, it was crucial for Indigenous peoples to come together as brothers and establish a unified front in the face of American colonialism.
Additionally, both Red Jacket and Tecumseh believed in the power of unity to defend their cultural and spiritual traditions. They saw themselves as part of a larger Indigenous community and sought to build solidarity among all Native American tribes. By emphasizing brotherhood, they aimed to foster a sense of shared identity and purpose among their people.
It is worth noting that while Red Jacket and Tecumseh did align themselves with the British government, their focus on fraternity and unity was not solely related to their support for British control of America. Rather, it stemmed from a desire to protect and preserve the rights and interests of their own peoples in the face of American colonization.
In conclusion, the emphasis on fraternity and unity in the speeches of Red Jacket and Tecumseh reflected the historical context of their time, marked by American expansionism and the aftermath of the Revolutionary War. They recognized the need for Indigenous peoples to come together as brothers to resist American encroachment and protect their cultural and spiritual traditions.