Argue for or against which source (Traditional Library Sources versus Web-based Research Sources) would be better to prepare for a debate on changing the state’s laws on smoking in public buildings. Identify the advantages, types of sources, etc., and provide answers for possible disadvantages
http://www.jiskha.com/display.cgi?id=1359473503
When preparing for a debate on changing the state's laws on smoking in public buildings, both traditional library sources and web-based research sources can be valuable. However, it is essential to consider the advantages and disadvantages of each to determine which source is better suited for your needs.
Advantages of Traditional Library Sources:
1. Credibility and reliability: Libraries often curate their collection based on the authority and quality of the sources, ensuring reliable information.
2. In-depth information: Libraries provide access to a wide range of books, academic journals, and other print materials that offer comprehensive research on a specific topic.
3. Peer-reviewed sources: Many traditional library sources undergo a rigorous peer-review process, ensuring higher quality and accuracy.
4. Physical browsing: Being physically present in a library allows you to browse through different books and documents, potentially stumbling upon valuable information that you may have overlooked.
Types of Traditional Library Sources:
1. Books: Libraries house a vast collection of books on various subjects, including public health, law, and social sciences.
2. Academic journals: Libraries subscribe to numerous scholarly journals that publish research on relevant topics.
3. Newspapers and magazines: These sources can provide current and historical perspectives on smoking laws, public opinion, and government policies.
Disadvantages of Traditional Library Sources:
1. Limited access: Not all libraries may have the desired books or resources, especially if they are outdated or specialized.
2. Time-consuming: Searching through physical materials can be time-consuming, particularly if you need to go through multiple books or articles.
3. Outdated information: Depending on the topic, older print resources may not reflect the latest research or changes in legislation.
Advantages of Web-based Research Sources:
1. Accessibility: The internet provides easy and instant access to vast amounts of information from around the world.
2. Updated information: Web-based sources can provide real-time news, studies, reports, and legal documents related to smoking laws.
3. Diverse sources: Online research allows you to access a wide range of sources, including government websites, research papers, expert blogs, and news articles.
4. Advanced search capabilities: Online search engines enable you to refine your search, allowing for targeted information retrieval.
Types of Web-based Research Sources:
1. Government websites: State, federal, or local government websites often contain legislative information, reports, and policy documents related to public smoking laws.
2. Research databases: Many academic databases offer access to scholarly articles and research studies on public health, legislation, and social impacts of smoking.
3. News websites: Online news outlets provide up-to-date coverage on relevant topics, including debates on smoking laws, public opinion, and health risks.
Disadvantages of Web-based Research Sources:
1. Credibility concerns: Not all web-based sources are equally reliable, and it can be challenging to determine the quality and authority of the information.
2. Biased or inaccurate information: The internet contains vast amounts of information, including biased or inaccurate content that may require validation before use.
3. Overwhelming volume: The abundance of online information can be overwhelming, requiring careful evaluation and selection of sources.
In summary, both traditional library sources and web-based research sources offer advantages and disadvantages for preparing a debate on changing smoking laws in public buildings. A well-rounded approach would involve utilizing both types of sources, effectively leveraging the credibility and depth of traditional library materials while tapping into the accessibility and timeliness of web-based research.