strength of the arguments about Tarbell’s position
on women suffrage
What do you think?
Tarbell
argued that traditional female roles had been belittled by women’s rights advocates
and that women’s contributions belonged in the private sphere."
Tarbell also argued that women showed a lot of creativity as home makers
that Men think their superior
women haven't been given credit for their accomplishments.
youre right i agree
so i need to do an essay
Write an essay that analyzes the strength of the arguments about Tarbell’s position
on women suffrage in at least two of these texts based on the given reasoning and
evidence.
can i put this
Tarbell position on women's suffrage was that she opposed it. "Tarbell argued that traditional female roles had been belittled by women’s rights advocates and that women’s contributions belonged in the private sphere." She argued that women showed a lot of creativity as home makers, and that should be it.
In “Ida Tarbell: Life and Works” and “Ida Tarbell” Biographies, Tarbell argued that “traditional female roles had been belittled by women’s rights advocates and that women’s contributions belonged in the private sphere." She opposed this because it contradicted the roles of women which were to stay home and take care of the household duties and children.
i would add "Many woman suffer but Ida Tarbell changed that".
is thhis good?
In “Ida Tarbell: Life and Works” and “Ida Tarbell” Biographies, Tarbell argued that “traditional female roles had been belittled by women’s rights advocates and that women’s contributions belonged in the private sphere." She opposed this because it contradicted the roles of women which were to stay home and take care of the household duties and children.
Despite her accomplishment, of being the most influential women in the country she rejected the status of role model. With her accomplishment you would have thought that she would actually encourage the movement, but no she didn’t, she still despised it.
YES good job! Nice Essay! i would give it an A+
:) thank you
To determine the strength of the arguments about Ida Tarbell's position on women's suffrage, we need to analyze the evidence and evaluate the logical soundness of the arguments presented. Here's how you can do it:
1. Research Tarbell's stance on women's suffrage: Look for primary sources such as essays, articles, or speeches where Ida Tarbell expressed her opinion on women's suffrage. By analyzing her own words, you can understand her position better and evaluate the strength of arguments based on her views.
2. Identify supporting evidence: Examine the arguments in favor of Tarbell's position on women's suffrage. Look for evidence, examples, or logical reasoning that support her stance. This could include quotes from her writings, her involvement in suffrage campaigns, or her advocacy for women's rights.
3. Evaluate the credibility of the sources: Consider the credibility of the sources you've found. Assess the author's qualifications, expertise, and potential biases. A strong argument would be supported by reliable sources, such as reputable publications or well-respected historians.
4. Assess logical consistency: Examine the coherence of the arguments. Do they present a clear chain of reasoning? Are they internally consistent? Ensure that the arguments rely on factual evidence rather than emotions or personal opinions.
5. Analyze opposing viewpoints: To fully evaluate the strength of arguments, consider the counterarguments against Tarbell's position on women's suffrage. Look for opposing viewpoints, criticisms, or alternative interpretations. Evaluating counterarguments will help you understand the broader context and potential weaknesses in Tarbell's stance.
6. Consider historical context: Keep in mind the historical context of the women's suffrage movement during Tarbell's time. This context can provide insights into societal norms, cultural expectations, and political dynamics that may have influenced Tarbell's position, as well as the arguments made for or against suffrage.
By following these steps and conducting a comprehensive analysis, you can evaluate the strength of arguments surrounding Tarbell's position on women's suffrage. Remember to critically assess the evidence, consider opposing viewpoints, and understand the historical context to form a well-rounded evaluation.