Alice and Andrew are discussing thesis development. Alice argues that a topic becomes a thesis if we want to write about the topic. Andrew, on the other hand, maintains that a topic is not a thesis but that a thesis is the foundation of a topic. Who is correct?
A. Alice is correct.
B. Andrew is correct.
C. Neither Alice nor Andrew is correct.
D. Both are partially correct.
My answer is C
I agree.
C. Neither Alice nor Andrew is correct.
A thesis is a statement or an argument that a writer presents as the main idea or focus of an essay or research paper. It is the central claim that the writer wants to support and develop through evidence and analysis.
A topic, on the other hand, is the general subject or area of interest that the writer wants to explore. It provides a starting point for research and writing but is not the same as a thesis.
Therefore, Alice is incorrect in asserting that a topic becomes a thesis if we want to write about it. And Andrew is incorrect in claiming that a thesis is the foundation of a topic. A thesis is developed based on an analysis and understanding of a topic, but it does not define or create the topic itself.
In order to determine who is correct, we need to understand the definitions of a topic and a thesis.
A topic is a broad subject or area of interest that can be explored and discussed. It is the starting point of a research or writing process.
A thesis, on the other hand, is a specific claim or argument that is presented in a written work. It is a statement that is supported by evidence and reasoning.
Based on these definitions, we can see that neither Alice nor Andrew is fully correct.
Alice argues that a topic becomes a thesis if we want to write about it. While it is true that a topic can be developed into a thesis, simply wanting to write about a topic does not automatically transform it into a thesis. A thesis requires more specificity, evidence, and a clear argument.
Andrew maintains that a thesis is the foundation of a topic. This perspective also misses the mark. A thesis is not the foundation of a topic. Instead, a thesis is built upon the exploration and development of a topic.
Therefore, the correct answer to the question is C. Neither Alice nor Andrew is fully correct. Both perspectives are partially correct in certain aspects, but neither fully captures the relationship between a topic and a thesis.