Hello I am having a bit of trouble with my DQ for this week and I was wondering if anybody could help me?
The DQ for this week is:
This week we are looking at symbolism and given the example of a Treaty signing. Tell me what you think about the entire situation regarding the omission of Native American women by the white artist and their inclusion by the Native artist. Do you see this as just a sign of that time or did it hold more symbolic meaning?
Thank you very much!!!
The way this site works is that YOU write up what YOU THINK, and someone here will be happy to critique your thinking and writing.
Of course! I'd be happy to help you with your DQ. It seems like you are exploring the symbolism behind the omission of Native American women in a treaty signing painting by a white artist, as compared to their inclusion in a painting by a Native artist. You are wondering if this omission was merely a reflection of the time or if it held a deeper symbolic meaning.
To address this question, it would be helpful to gather information about the historical context and symbolism related to the representation of Native American women in art during that time period. Here's how you can approach finding information to support your analysis:
1. Research the historical context: Start by understanding the historical period when the treaty signing took place and the prevailing attitudes and cultural dynamics during that time. Look for information on the societal position of Native American women, their roles, and the way they were perceived by white society.
2. Explore the artists' backgrounds: Learn about the background and perspectives of both the white artist and the Native artist who created these paintings. Investigate their cultural and artistic influences, their beliefs, and any statements they made about their artwork. This will help you understand the artists' intentions behind their representations.
3. Analyze the symbolism in the paintings: Examine the composition, symbolism, and visual elements used in both paintings. Look for any symbols or motifs that represent power, identity, or representation. Consider the positioning and portrayal of individuals in each painting and how it contributes to conveying different meanings.
4. Consult scholarly sources and art critics: Look for academic articles, books, or essays that discuss the representation of Native American women in art, particularly during the time period of the treaty signing. Analyze different perspectives and interpretations put forward by experts in the field. Their analysis can provide valuable insights and support for your argument.
5. Formulate your response: Based on the research you've gathered, develop a well-supported answer to the DQ. Consider the historical context, the artists' intentions, the symbolism in the paintings, and the perspectives of scholars and critics. Clearly explain your viewpoint, considering whether the exclusion or inclusion of Native American women was a reflection of the time or if it held deeper symbolic meaning.
Remember to cite your sources and provide evidence to back up your claims. Good luck with your assignment, and feel free to ask if you have any more specific questions along the way!