Document F - Source:Richard B. Morris, The Basic Ideas of Alexander Hamilton. (1957).
Clash Over States Rights
"A firm Union will be of the utmost moment to the peace and liberty of the states, a barrier against domestic faction and insurrection.” (1787)
“A state government will never be the rival power of the general government.”
“As to the destruction of state governments, the great and real anxiety is to be able to preserve the national (government) from the too potent and counteracting influences of those state governments.”
“Hence, a disposition on my part towards a liberal construction of the powers of the national government, and to erect every fence to guard it from depredations which is, in my opinion, consistent with constitutional propriety. As to any combination to prostrate the state governments, I disavow and deny it.”
Document F – 6) In his ideas, how does Alexander Hamilton believe state governments should exist in relation to the federal government? Should they be weaker, equal or stronger than Federal government? Cite your evidence or this will be considered an incorrect answer.
I'll be glad to check your answer.
I asked my parents and they gave me the answer - Hamilton believe state governments should never be stronger or oppose the federal government.
But they tell me to find the evidence myself. I am not sure if I am correct...I would say the state government should be weaker than federal government as “A state government will never be the rival power of the general government.”
Am I correct, Ms. Sue? :)
You (and your parents) are right.
You might also include this sentence as another piece of evidence:
"As to the destruction of state governments, the great and real anxiety is to be able to preserve the national (government) from the too potent and counteracting influences of those state governments.”
Thanks again Ms.Sue, you are the best ^.^
You're very welcome, Cassidy.
According to document F, Alexander Hamilton believed that state governments should be weaker than the federal government. He states that a firm union is necessary for the peace and liberty of the states, serving as a barrier against domestic faction and insurrection. Hamilton also argues that state governments will never be a rival power to the general government and that the real concern is preserving the national government from the influences of state governments. Additionally, he expresses a disposition towards a liberal construction of the powers of the national government and erecting fences to guard it from state government depredations. Therefore, Hamilton's ideas indicate that state governments should be weaker than the federal government.
To arrive at this conclusion, one must examine the provided source, which is Richard B. Morris' book titled "The Basic Ideas of Alexander Hamilton" published in 1957. By referencing this source, the statements made by Hamilton can be analyzed to determine his beliefs regarding the relative strength of state governments in relation to the federal government.