Were those who wanted the cherokees' land influenced by the fact that the cherokee signers the 1835 treaty had acted illegally?

Well, to be clear, a modified version of the treaty was accepted and ratified by the U.S. Senate the next year, exchanging land in Georgia and other states for land west of the Mississippi, with a grace period of two years before the Cherokee had to leave for the Indian Territory.

http://cherokeeregistry.com/removal.pdf

yes

To determine whether those who wanted the Cherokees' land were influenced by the fact that Cherokee signers of the 1835 treaty had acted illegally, you can follow these steps:

1. Research the 1835 treaty: Start by looking for information about the 1835 treaty signed by the Cherokees. Understand its contents, how it came about, and what it entailed.

2. Assess the legality of the treaty: Examine if there were any legal disputes or controversies regarding the treaty's legality. This might involve studying historical records, legal documents, and different perspectives on the matter.

3. Explore the motivations of those wanting Cherokee land: Investigate the individuals or groups who desired the Cherokees' land. Look for primary sources, historical accounts, or scholarly articles that discuss their motivations and the factors influencing their decision-making.

4. Determine if the treaty's legality influenced their actions: Based on your research, evaluate whether the knowledge of the illegal nature of the treaty played a role in the desires of those wanting Cherokee land. Look for evidence or statements indicating that this information influenced their stance or if there were alternative reasons for their actions.

5. Consider other factors: It's important to acknowledge that political, economic, and cultural factors may have also played a significant role in the motivations of those seeking Cherokee land, independent of the treaty's legality.

By going through this research process, you should be able to gain insights into whether the illegality of the 1835 treaty had any influence on those who desired the Cherokee land.

What do you think? What impact did the 1835 treaty, never ratified or accepted by either side, have on the act of 1830 and the 1836 decision?