According to the speaker in "Mending Wall" by Robert Frost, why does the neighbor feel that good walls make good neighbors?
A. They create a barrier from having to talk to one another often.
B. They maintain privacy and prevent meddling.
C. They physically display the distance one wants to have between them, and others
D. They increase the desire for neighbors to want to talk
I'm thinking B?
YASSS
Well, well, well, it seems like you're looking for an answer in the land of Frost! Ah, the enigmatic "Mending Wall." Now, let me put on my clowny spectacles and break it down for you.
According to the jolly speaker in the poem, the neighbor feels that good walls make good neighbors because they maintain privacy and prevent meddling. So, my dear friend, you are absolutely right! Option B it is!
Just remember, sometimes it's good to mend walls, but it's even better to fill them with circus decorations and turn them into a juggling show. Who needs to keep neighbors out when you can invite them in for some laughter and fun, right?
Yes, you are correct. According to the speaker in "Mending Wall" by Robert Frost, the neighbor feels that good walls make good neighbors because they maintain privacy and prevent meddling (Option B). The neighbor values the physical boundary provided by the wall, as it creates a clear separation and allows each person to maintain their own space and privacy.
In order to determine the correct answer, let's examine the speaker's words in the poem "Mending Wall" by Robert Frost. The famous line "Good fences make good neighbors" is repeated twice in the poem, once at the beginning and again towards the end. The speaker presents this statement as a saying passed down from his father's neighbor, indicating that it is a commonly held belief.
To understand the neighbor's perspective, we need to consider the context of the poem. The poem describes the annual ritual of mending a stone wall that separates the speaker's land from his neighbor's land. The neighbor stubbornly holds onto the tradition of maintaining the wall, stating, "Good fences make good neighbors."
Analyzing the options provided:
A. "They create a barrier from having to talk to one another often" - The speaker in the poem actually enjoys conversing and interacting with his neighbor, so this option does not reflect their perspective.
B. "They maintain privacy and prevent meddling" - This option aligns with the idea that good walls ensure privacy and prevent unwanted interference. The neighbor might value the wall as a way to establish personal boundaries and keep others from intruding.
C. "They physically display the distance one wants to have between them and others" - While the wall does represent a physical separation, the neighbor doesn't necessarily seem to express a desire for distance. So, this option is not the primary focus of his belief.
D. "They increase the desire for neighbors to want to talk" - The neighbor, as portrayed in the poem, appears to prefer maintaining a certain level of distance and separation, rather than actively seeking out conversation. Therefore, this option is not consistent with the neighbor's perspective.
Based on the above analysis, option B, "They maintain privacy and prevent meddling," is the most accurate interpretation of the neighbor's belief that good walls make good neighbors.