If you have a map of 19th century US and the names of the states are changed to Irish names, ie: Irish Sea , Mulligan, etc. And the question was to compare the map to a typical US map, would you answer with just explaining the obvious changes, or is there some hidden message to this? What would the purpose, other than, come Irish spoke Gaelic and to show that the US is their new "promised land" be. Other than that, I have seached for some 11th grade worthy answer to these questions and have not found one.

Question

If you have a map of 19th century US and the names of the states are changed to Irish names, ie: Irish Sea , Mulligan, etc. And the question was to compare the map to a typical US map, would you answer with just explaining the obvious changes, or is there some hidden message to this? What would the purpose, other than, come Irish spoke Gaelic and to show that the US is their new "promised land" be. Other than that, I have seached for some 11th grade worthy answer to these questions and have not found one.

Thak you.

Answer 1

State names usually have some historical significance, named after a native American chief or tribe (eg Massachusetts) or Historical Leader (Viginia for virgin queen Elizabeth or Pennsylvania for William Penn etc) or place where some settlers came from (New Whatever)

Answer 2

If you're comparing a map of 19th century US with Irish names to a typical US map, the obvious changes would primarily involve the substitution of state names with Irish names. For example, instead of states like California or New York, you might have names like Irish Sea or Mulligan. This type of change can be seen as a playful exercise or simply an imaginative way to alter the familiar geography.

However, if you're looking for a deeper meaning or hidden message behind such a map, it might be challenging to find one. While it is true that many Irish people migrated to the US during the 19th century and saw America as a new "promised land," it is unclear if the map you described serves that purpose. Without more context or specific information about the map's origin or intention, it would be difficult to determine if there is a symbolic or profound message behind it.

Regarding your search for an 11th-grade worthy answer, it seems that the purpose behind this particular map may not be linked to any significant historical or cultural resonances beyond the substitution of names. If this is a school assignment, and you are not able to find substantial information or a hidden message, it might be best to focus on the more obvious changes and potential cultural significance of Irish migration to the US instead.