When the Framers created the legislative branch of government, why did they decide that this branch would have a bicameral structure?
http://www.jiskha.com/display.cgi?id=1476121237
The Framers of the United States Constitution decided to create a bicameral structure for the legislative branch for several reasons. Here is a step-by-step explanation:
1. Historical Influences: The concept of a bicameral legislature was not new at the time of the Constitutional Convention. The British Parliament, with its House of Commons and House of Lords, served as a reference point for the Framers.
2. Representation: One key reason for a bicameral structure was to address the issue of representation. The Framers wanted to create a system that balanced the interests of both the states and the people.
3. The Great Compromise: The Great Compromise, also known as the Connecticut Compromise, was a crucial agreement that led to the bicameral structure. It proposed a compromise between the Virginia Plan, which favored representation based on population, and the New Jersey Plan, which called for equal representation for all states.
4. House of Representatives: The lower house, known as the House of Representatives, was designed to represent the people. The number of representatives in each state would be based on its population, ensuring that larger states had a greater voice.
5. Senate: The upper house, known as the Senate, was created to represent the states as equal entities. Each state would have two senators, regardless of its population. This arrangement aimed to protect the interests of smaller states and prevent domination by more populous ones.
6. Checks and Balances: The bicameral structure also served as a system of checks and balances. Both houses of Congress would be required to approve legislation, ensuring that laws were carefully considered and passed through a deliberative process.
7. Compromise and Consensus: The Framers understood that a bicameral legislature would require negotiations and compromise between the two houses. This approach encouraged cooperation and consensus-building among legislators.
Overall, the bicameral structure of the legislative branch was designed to balance representation between the states and the people, promote checks and balances, and encourage compromise and consensus in the lawmaking process.
The Framers of the United States Constitution decided to create a bicameral legislative branch, consisting of the House of Representatives and the Senate, for a few key reasons.
1. Representation: One of the primary reasons for the bicameral structure was to balance the interests of states with different sizes and populations. The House of Representatives was designed to be based on population, ensuring that states with larger populations had more representation. On the other hand, the Senate was created to provide equal representation to each state, regardless of its population. This compromise helped smaller states feel that they would not be overshadowed by larger states in the legislative process.
2. Check and Balance: The bicameral structure also serves as a system of checks and balances. Each house of Congress acts as a check on the other, ensuring that legislation undergoes thorough debate, scrutiny, and revision before passing into law. This system helps prevent hasty decision-making and reduces the power of any single branch of government.
3. Deliberation and Debate: The Framers wanted to ensure that legislation would be carefully considered and debated. They believed that having two separate chambers would provide a forum for more extensive examination of issues. The House, with its larger number of representatives, is more responsive to the will of the people, while the Senate, with its smaller size and longer terms, is seen as a more deliberate body.
4. Historical Precedent: The bicameral structure also drew inspiration from the British Parliament, where the House of Commons and the House of Lords represented different aspects of society. The Framers viewed this as a successful model and sought to incorporate it into the American system.
To understand why the Framers chose a bicameral legislature, it is essential to study their deliberations during the Constitutional Convention and the historical context in which they operated. Examining the Federalist Papers, primary sources, and historical accounts of the Founding era can provide further insight into their decision-making process.