What does Robert Bartlett in the "The Natural and the Supernatural in the Middle Ages" say about things about being beyond nature and what examples does he give?
Also,what does Robert Bartlett in the "The Natural and the Supernatural in the Middle Ages" say about things being natural and what examples does he give of them?
How was the dichotomy maintained between the natural and supernatural in medieval times ? ( Another of the questions I need to answer regarding The Natural and the Supernatural in the Middle ages for an essay)
Have you read Bartlett? I advise that you do so to discover what he says.
Yes I have but he is so vague about what he considers things being natural in the Middle Ages that I decided to ask for help and the same thing with the supernatural I've got the gist, I just need some rock-hard examples to make my essay that much better for both what he considers natural and supernatural . From what I could understand the distinction between the natural and the supernatural was maintained through what the Church said was natural and supernatural, so such things as someone being cured from a incurable disease would be considered supernatural and a miracle from the hand of God as it would go against nature to be cured of such a disease as for the natural, things such as the harvest would be considered natural as it doesn't go against nature rather it is a natural way of being, as it happens the same time every year.
If you could please clarify,Reed, that would be fantastic.
Thanks,
Alex
To find the specific information you are looking for in Robert Bartlett's book "The Natural and the Supernatural in the Middle Ages," I suggest following these steps:
1. Access the book: Start by obtaining a copy of the book either through a library, academic database, or online bookseller.
2. Familiarize yourself with the content: Skim through the table of contents, introduction, and chapter headings to get an overview of the structure and main themes of the book. This will help you locate the relevant sections more quickly.
3. Read the relevant chapters: Based on the question you have, focus on reading the chapters or sections that address the topics of "things beyond nature" and "things natural" in the Middle Ages. Pay attention to the author's main arguments, examples, and explanations.
4. Take notes: While reading, take organized notes on the important points, arguments, and examples mentioned by Bartlett. This will help you remember and reference the information later on.
5. Refer to footnotes and references: Bartlett may provide additional sources or references related to the topics discussed. Check footnotes or the bibliography for further reading, which can help you explore the subject in greater depth if needed.
Regarding the dichotomy between the natural and supernatural in medieval times, Bartlett's book should provide valuable insights. Follow a similar process:
1. Read relevant chapters: Identify the sections or chapters that discuss the dichotomy between the natural and supernatural in medieval times. Take note of Bartlett's analysis, arguments, and any examples he presents.
2. Consider the author's viewpoint: Pay attention to Bartlett's interpretation and explanation of how the dichotomy was maintained. Consider the social, cultural, religious, and philosophical factors that influenced this division.
3. Note key points: As you read, highlight or jot down the key ideas, explanations, and examples provided by Bartlett to support his argument about the maintenance of the natural-supernatural dichotomy.
4. Cross-reference with other sources: To strengthen your essay, consider cross-referencing Bartlett's arguments with other scholarly sources on the topic. This will provide a well-rounded understanding and support for your own analysis.
Remember to appropriately cite and provide proper credit to Bartlett and any other sources you use in your essay.