Login or Sign Up
Menu
Ask a New Question

Which of the following represents faulty logic

A. Poor people get sick.
B. Children are expensive to raise.
C. The profit from selling children will improve the economy.
D. Eating children will decrease the population.

I chose A, am I correct?

Yes, you are correct. Option A, "Poor people get sick," represents faulty logic. This statement assumes that all poor people get sick, which is an erroneous generalization. It is an example of faulty logic because it uses a stereotype or a broad assumption without sufficient evidence or reasoning.

Yes, you are correct. Option A, "Poor people get sick," represents faulty logic. This statement makes a broad generalization by assuming that all poor people get sick without providing any evidence or reasoning to support this claim. It is important to distinguish between correlation and causation when making logical statements. While it may be true that there is a higher incidence of illness among poor individuals, directly attributing all illness to poverty without considering other factors would be an oversimplification and a fallacy.

Actually, as stated, none of them are faulty. If A is to assume that a condition of being poor is to get sick, therefore all poor people get sick, then A is faulty, but not as stated. Poor people do get sick, but so do rich people, so it's not illogical.