You are a first responder to a suspected terrorist incident. As you arrive, a sniper shoots two firefighters. You then see a suspicious-looking man, with Middle Eastern features, leaving the scene. Later, while helping victims, you find a spent rifle shell casing on the ground. You should:
A. not do anything but continue to treat victims.
B. tell police about the man and point out the shell casing.
C. pick up the casing and give it to the police when you can.
D. point out the casing to the police, but pointing out someone with Middle Eastern features as being "suspicious" is profiling, which is illegal.
I think it's B, but not sure.
I think you're right.
I agree, too -- not only because of the profiling angle, but also because, if the guy isn't around anymore, what's the point of giving a rather general description?
In a situation like this, it is important to prioritize the safety and well-being of the victims while also assisting law enforcement in their investigation. Let's break down the possible options:
A. Not do anything but continue to treat victims: While providing immediate medical aid to the victims is crucial, it is also important to help law enforcement gather as much information as possible to apprehend the responsible party.
B. Tell police about the man and point out the shell casing: This option is a reasonable course of action. Informing the police about the suspicious-looking man and drawing their attention to the shell casing could potentially provide vital details for their investigation.
C. Pick up the casing and give it to the police when you can: While taking the initiative to gather evidence is commendable, it is essential to ensure your personal safety and the safety of those around you. It would be best to inform the police of the casing's location and allow them to handle the evidence collection.
D. Point out the casing to the police, but profiling someone with Middle Eastern features as being "suspicious" is illegal: Profiling is indeed illegal and should not be practiced. However, if you solely based your suspicions on someone's Middle Eastern features, it would not be appropriate. Nonetheless, if there are other valid reasons to suspect someone, such as their behavior or actions, it is essential to communicate this information to the authorities.
In this case, option B seems to be the most appropriate choice. By informing the police about the suspicious-looking man and pointing out the shell casing, you are providing them with potentially valuable information to aid their investigation without engaging in illegal profiling.