Nathan argues that each paragraph in a narrative should support the author's thesis. Nan says that
paragraphs in a narrative should illuminate some part of the action. Which one is correct?
A. Neither Nathan nor Nan is correct.
B. Both Nathan and Nan are correct.
C. Only Nan is correct.
D. Only Nathan is correct.
my answer is c.
No
Yes. I think it's C.
I do disagree.
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/narrative
I agree with C, too.
Narratives generally don't have thesis statements, so there's no need for paragraphs to support one.
Narratives are told to develop characters and move the action of a story along.
Thanks Ms Sue and Writeacher
You're welcome, Diana.
i think it is c
C. Only Nan is correct. Narratives generally don't have thesis statements. Sometimes they do but you have to think like the book which Narratives dont have thesis. I got this right on my test.
To determine which response is correct, we need to understand the definitions and purpose of paragraphs in a narrative.
A paragraph is a unit of text that presents a distinct idea or point. In a narrative, paragraphs play a vital role in structuring the story, conveying information, and guiding the reader's understanding. But how do they relate to the thesis and the action?
A thesis is the main idea or argument that the author wants to convey in a narrative. It serves as the central focus of the story and helps to guide the narrative's direction. The thesis is typically introduced in the introduction or early on in the narrative.
On the other hand, the action refers to the sequence of events, activities, or incidents that take place in the narrative. It comprises the plot and character interactions, driving the story forward and keeping the reader engaged.
Now, let's evaluate Nathan and Nan's perspectives in light of these definitions.
Nathan argues that each paragraph in a narrative should support the author's thesis. This means that every paragraph should provide evidence, examples, or reasoning that directly connects to and reinforces the thesis. Nathan believes that the primary purpose of paragraphs in a narrative is to contribute to the development and defense of the main argument.
Nan, on the other hand, suggests that paragraphs in a narrative should illuminate some part of the action. This means that paragraphs should provide description, dialogue, or details that enhance the reader's understanding of the events taking place. Nan thinks that paragraphs should primarily focus on portraying and highlighting different aspects of the story's action.
A. Neither Nathan nor Nan is correct. One way to determine this is by considering that each paragraph can fulfill multiple functions simultaneously. It is possible for paragraphs to support the author's thesis and illuminate the action at the same time.
B. Both Nathan and Nan are correct. This response acknowledges that paragraphs can serve both purposes. Some paragraphs may primarily support the thesis, while others may mainly illuminate the action. Both perspectives are valid, and the combination of these two approaches can help create a well-rounded narrative.
C. Only Nan is correct. This response asserts that paragraphs solely exist to illuminate the action and disregards the importance of supporting the author's thesis. However, this perspective overlooks the significance of providing evidence and analysis to reinforce the central argument of a narrative.
D. Only Nathan is correct. This response claims that the sole purpose of paragraphs is to support the thesis, neglecting the importance of portraying the action. While supporting the thesis is crucial, a narrative is more than just the argument it presents. Ignoring the role of paragraphs in depicting the story's action would limit the reader's engagement and comprehension.
Based on the explanations above, the most accurate response would be B. Both Nathan and Nan are correct.