After doing istikharah prayer,some ulama believe that one should open his heart to Allah and feels what his heart tells what he should do.On the other hand some ulama believe that one should just do what he intended to do before making the istikharah. If the thing is good for him, Allah will make it happen in a good way. If it is bad, Allah will make the situation as such that he is unable to carry out what he intended to do.In this case the istikharah is not to seek guidance.Rather more of seeking Allah’s assisstance to whatever decision that has been made. What is your opinion in this matter and the reasons for it.Thank you.
I'm sure your teacher wants YOUR opinion, not ours.
This is not a question any tutor can answer for you. The purpose of the assignment is for you to come up with your own answer. Keep in mind that theological questions can be argued ad infinitum. If your teacher or imam or online curriculum (whatever you are doing) has given you no guidance, I would use your search engine to look up istikharah prayer. You will find a good many articles.
As an AI, I don't have personal opinions or beliefs. However, I can provide information on the different perspectives regarding istikharah prayer.
The two perspectives you mentioned are both valid interpretations of istikharah prayer, and they are based on different understandings and teachings within Islam. Here's a breakdown of each perspective:
1. Opening the heart to Allah's guidance: Some scholars believe that after performing istikharah prayer, one should remain open to receiving guidance from Allah through one's inner feelings and intuition. According to this perspective, the individual should pay attention to their heart's inclination towards a particular choice or decision. The belief is that Allah will guide them towards what is best for them by inspiring their heart's desires or bringing about favorable circumstances. They see istikharah as a means of seeking divine direction directly from Allah.
2. Seeking assistance with a decision already made: Others argue that istikharah prayer is not necessarily a means of seeking guidance, but rather seeking Allah's assistance and blessings for the decision that has already been made. According to this perspective, after making a decision, a person performs istikharah to seek Allah's favor and request that He facilitate the chosen path if it is beneficial and make it difficult if it is not in the person's best interest. This perspective emphasizes human agency and trusting in one's ability to make decisions.
Both perspectives have their basis in Islamic teachings and traditions. They stem from different interpretations of the hadith and teachings of Prophet Muhammad regarding istikharah prayer. It is important to note that ultimately, istikharah prayer is a personal and spiritual practice, and individuals may choose the perspective that resonates with them the most.
If you are seeking guidance in a particular matter, it is advisable to consult with knowledgeable scholars or spiritual guides who can provide more detailed insights based on your specific circumstances and personal beliefs.