How did Calhoun and South Carolina propose to test the theory of nullification? What factors contributed to their decision?
http://www.ushistory.org/us/24c.asp
To understand how Calhoun and South Carolina proposed to test the theory of nullification and the factors that contributed to their decision, we need to delve into the historical context and background.
In the early 19th century, the United States was divided over issues of states' rights versus federal authority. John C. Calhoun, a prominent politician from South Carolina, championed the theory of nullification. Nullification held that states had the right to nullify or reject federal laws they deemed unconstitutional within their borders.
Calhoun and South Carolina proposed to test the theory of nullification in response to the Tariff of 1828, also known as the "Tariff of Abominations." This protective tariff imposed high import duties on manufactured goods, benefiting the North while harming the Southern economy. South Carolina, heavily dependent on agriculture and exports, strongly opposed this tariff and believed it violated states' rights.
To formally test the theory of nullification, South Carolina adopted the "Ordinance of Nullification" in November 1832. This ordinance declared the Tariffs of 1828 and 1832 null and void within the state's boundaries, effectively nullifying federal law. It also stated that any attempt by the federal government to collect the tariffs would lead to South Carolina's secession from the Union.
Several key factors contributed to their decision to test nullification. Firstly, the economic impact of the tariffs on South Carolina was significant, threatening the state's agricultural economy and its reliance on exported goods. Additionally, South Carolina's political leaders, led by Calhoun, firmly believed in the principles of states' rights and viewed nullification as a means to protect their sovereignty. They felt it was vital to assert their authority over the federal government, thereby defending their interests and preserving their way of life.
The nullification crisis escalated when President Andrew Jackson, a strong supporter of federal authority, responded to South Carolina's actions. He declared that nullification amounted to treason and threatened to use military force to enforce federal law within the state's borders. To avoid armed conflict, a compromise was later reached in the form of the "Tariff of 1833," which gradually reduced the tariff rates over a ten-year period. This resolution defused tensions and prevented a larger crisis, ultimately avoiding a potential test of nullification by force.
In summary, Calhoun and South Carolina proposed to test the theory of nullification by declaring the Tariffs of 1828 and 1832 null and void within the state's boundaries. The adverse economic impact of these tariffs on South Carolina, combined with the state's strong belief in states' rights, led to their decision to assert their sovereignty and challenge federal authority. Ultimately, a compromise was reached, and nullification was not fully tested, avoiding a potential confrontation between state and federal powers.