English

posted by .

1. I studied math for 10 years, but I'm still not good at it.

2. I have studied for 10 years, but I'm still not good at it.

(Which one is grammatical? Do we have to sue the present tense or the present perfect tense here?)

  • English -

    I think #2 is better. The "still" implies that the study is continuing, rather than having been finished in the past.

    #1 would be ok if it said something like

    I studied math for ten years, but never really learned it.

    #1 is still ok as it is, if you are discussing past activities, and are just saying that your ten years of study were wasted, because you are still not good at math. The meaning of "still" is different; it means "nevertheless" rather than a continuing activity.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. English

    I am in USA for last 14 years almost but still have an accent. I tried hard to get rid of my accent and speek as good as one american born could, but I could do it. Can anyone recommend me anything helpful to correct my accent?
  2. SAT

    is there any helpful practice sat tests online other than the college board?
  3. math 12

    From 85 Records at D.S. Collegiate, the following data was collected: 12 studied Sociology, Economics and Accounting, 27 studied sociology and accounting, 20 studied economics and accounting, 21 studied economics and sociology, 36 …
  4. English

    1. She studied hard, only to fail. 2. She studied hard, but failed. 3. She studied hard, but she failed. (Does #1 mean #2 and #3?
  5. poetry, please comment

    Still So New to You Standing alone Looking' at the moon Why'd you have to leave me so soon I was still so new to you I didn't have a clue Barely even two I was still so new to you still so new....... written by: kathy a.... thanks …
  6. English

    1. If I had studied hard, I could have gotten a higher score. 2. If I had studied hard, I could have gotten a better result. 3. If I had studied hard, I could have gotten a good/better grade. 4. If I had studied hard, I could not have …
  7. English Ms sue

    Is there any good rules to linking verbs?
  8. English

    1. I studied math for 10 years, but I'm still not good at it. 2. I have studied math for 10 years, but I'm still not good at it. ----------------- Which one is grammatical?
  9. Maths

    In a school of 100 students,70 studied English,30 studied French and 50 studied Latin.everyone studied atleast one of the subject,and 44 studied exactly two of the subject.how many students studied all the subject.
  10. Math

    In a school of 100 students,70 studied English,30 studied French and 50 studied Latin.everyone studied atleast one of the subject,and 44 studied exactly two of the subject.how many students studied all the subject.

More Similar Questions