Of progressive administration and progressive pedagogy, which approach is most effective for learners today and why?
I have researched both and cannot decide.
Make two lists side by side. Put the positives of one approach in one column and the positives of the other approach in the other.
Then do the same for the negatives.
That should help you make a decision.
Thank you Ms. Sue
You're welcome, Cathy.
Deciding which approach, progressive administration or progressive pedagogy, is most effective for learners today can be a subjective matter and depend on various factors such as the context, goals, and the needs of the learners. However, I can provide some insights into each approach, explain how they work, and highlight their potential strengths and limitations.
Progressive administration focuses on promoting student-centered and experiential learning by creating an environment that supports collaboration, critical thinking, and creativity. It involves creating flexible structures that empower students to take ownership of their learning journey. Key elements of progressive administration may include project-based learning, interdisciplinary approaches, and individualized instruction.
To determine the effectiveness of progressive administration, you can consider the following steps:
1. Research: Look for studies and articles that discuss the impact of progressive administration on student outcomes. Examine empirical evidence and look for studies that have been conducted with similar populations or in similar contexts to your situation.
2. Case studies: Explore specific examples of schools or educational institutions that have implemented progressive administration and examine their success stories, challenges, and student feedback. This can help you understand how the approach works in practice.
3. Expert opinions: Seek out educational experts or professionals who have experience with progressive administration. Listen to their perspectives, attend conferences, or join online discussions related to progressive administration to gain insights from those who have studied or implemented the approach.
4. Consider your context: Reflect on the specific needs, goals, and resources available in your educational setting. Consider the characteristics of your learners, curriculum requirements, available technology, and support systems. Progressive administration may suit certain contexts more than others, so understanding your own context is crucial in making an informed decision.
Progressive pedagogy, on the other hand, focuses on learner-centered instructional practices within the classroom. It emphasizes active engagement, critical thinking, and problem-solving, with a focus on the individual needs and interests of each learner. Key elements of progressive pedagogy may include inquiry-based learning, cooperative group work, and the integration of real-world applications.
To determine the effectiveness of progressive pedagogy, you can follow similar steps as for progressive administration:
1. Research: Look for studies and articles that discuss the impact of progressive pedagogy on student learning outcomes. Examine empirical evidence and ensure the studies align with your context.
2. Classroom observations: Observe classrooms or schools that incorporate progressive pedagogy. Pay attention to student engagement, motivation, and how learning is facilitated. This can provide firsthand insights into how the approach works and its potential effectiveness.
3. Expert opinions: Seek out educational experts or professionals who have expertise in progressive pedagogy. Learn from their experiences, attend workshops or conferences, and join professional networks to gain insights from those who have successfully implemented the approach.
4. Consider your context: Reflect on the specific needs, goals, and resources available in your educational setting. Consider how progressive pedagogy aligns with your curriculum, assessment requirements, available resources, and your learners' characteristics. Progressive pedagogy may require a shift in instructional practices and support systems, so understanding your context is crucial.
Ultimately, the effectiveness of either approach will depend on various contextual factors, such as the learners' needs, available resources, and the goals of the educational setting. It may be useful to consider a blended approach or adapt elements of both approaches to create an educational environment that best suits your specific context.