How did the shortage of good farmland contribute to the desire for Confederation?
What does your book say?
http://www.jiskha.com/display.cgi?id=1290816714
The shortage of good farmland in the mid-19th century in British North America played a significant role in the desire for Confederation. Here's an explanation of why this shortage led to the push for Confederation:
1. Population Pressure: The British North American colonies were experiencing a rapid increase in population due to various factors such as immigration, natural growth, and the arrival of displaced farmers from Europe. This led to a higher demand for land to cultivate crops and settle on.
2. Limited Agricultural Land: However, the available agricultural land in many colonies was insufficient to meet the growing population's needs. The existing farmland had become exhausted due to continuous cultivation without proper crop rotation and management practices. Additionally, the colonies' geographical limitations, including rugged terrains, forests, and swamps, made it challenging to expand farming areas.
3. Land Speculation and Monopolies: Another contributing factor was the issue of land speculation and monopolies. Some wealthy individuals or companies acquired vast amounts of fertile land and withheld it from settlement or sold it at exorbitant prices, hindering access to affordable farmland for ordinary settlers.
4. Economic Impact: The shortage of good farmland had adverse economic consequences for the colonies. As farming became difficult, settlers faced food shortages, inflation, and rising food prices. This situation created social and economic unrest, worsened living conditions, and limited opportunities for economic growth.
5. Regional Disparities: The inconsistent distribution of fertile land across the British North American colonies also led to regional disparities. Some regions, such as Upper Canada (Ontario), had more fertile land and prosperity, while others, like the Maritimes, struggled due to the scarcity of suitable agricultural land. These regional disparities created tensions and hindered cooperation among the colonies.
Given these circumstances, the desire for Confederation emerged as a potential solution to address the shortage of good farmland:
6. Consolidating Resources: By uniting the colonies and forming a federal government, it was believed that a more coordinated approach could be taken to manage and distribute resources effectively. This included implementing land reform policies that would address land monopolies and promote fair access to farmland.
7. Expansion Opportunities: Confederation provided the opportunity to expand the agricultural frontier westward, where there was a greater availability of fertile land. By joining forces, the colonies envisioned the construction of a transcontinental railway, facilitating transportation and increasing settlement in the western regions where better agricultural opportunities existed.
8. Economic and Political Stability: Confederation aimed to create a more stable and prosperous economic environment by establishing a common market, removing interprovincial trade barriers, and standardizing economic policies. This stability would attract investment, promote economic growth, and improve living conditions, including access to good farmland.
In conclusion, the shortage of good farmland in British North America contributed to the desire for Confederation as it created economic hardships, regional disparities, and limited opportunities for settlement. The idea of forming a united federal government provided a potential solution to address these issues by consolidating resources, expanding westward, and fostering economic and political stability.