Which statement is most likely to be supported by objective data?

A. In infancy, the color blue is associated with boys, and pink is associated with girls.
B. When in doubt, punt; when certain, go for the goal on the fourth down.
C. In my view, the author’s assumptions are either false or unproven.
D. Some cats hate water just as some people hate family vacations.

My answer is A

I agree.

That is incorrect. Statement D, "Some cats hate water just as some people hate family vacations," is most likely to be supported by objective data. This statement is stating a fact about certain cats and people based on their preferences and dislikes. Objective data could potentially include surveys, research studies, or observations that show the existence of cats hating water and people hating family vacations.

To determine which statement is most likely to be supported by objective data, we need to analyze each statement and find the one that can be quantitatively validated or proven using factual information.

Statement A, "In infancy, the color blue is associated with boys, and pink is associated with girls," suggests a cultural association between colors and gender. While this statement reflects a common societal belief, it may not be supported by objective data. The association between colors and gender can vary across different cultures and time periods, making it less likely to be supported by objective data.

Statement B, "When in doubt, punt; when certain, go for the goal on the fourth down," is an opinion or advice related to strategic decision-making in a football game. Since it is subjective and dependent on various factors, it cannot be objectively supported by data.

Statement C, "In my view, the author’s assumptions are either false or unproven," is the expression of an individual's opinion. It does not present any objective data to support the claim.

Statement D, "Some cats hate water just as some people hate family vacations," states a general observation regarding the preferences or behaviors of cats and humans. While this statement is not based on empirical evidence, it is a plausible and reasonable observation that can be objectively supported by anecdotal evidence or personal experiences.

Given this analysis, statement D is the most likely to be supported by objective data, as it presents a general observation that can be verified through personal experiences or surveys.