Compare the presidential and congressional plans of Reconstruction.
http://img.docstoccdn.com/thumb/orig/99847974.png
To compare the presidential and congressional plans of Reconstruction, we need to understand the key features and goals of each plan. Here's a step-by-step approach to comparing these plans.
1. Understand the context: Reconstruction refers to the period following the American Civil War, from 1865 to 1877, when the Union sought to address the issues related to the post-war integration of the Confederate states, the rights of freed slaves, and the rebuilding of the Southern economy.
2. Presidential Plan (also known as the Lincoln-Johnson Plan):
- Key features: Proposed by President Abraham Lincoln initially and then implemented by President Andrew Johnson after Lincoln's assassination in 1865.
- Amnesty and Pardon: Offered amnesty and pardons to most Confederates who pledged loyalty to the Union and agreed to follow the Emancipation Proclamation.
- State Governments: Recognized the reestablishment of state governments with the only requirement being the abolition of slavery (as per the 13th Amendment).
- Limited Political Rights for Freed Slaves: Did not grant full political rights, such as suffrage, to freed slaves.
- Disputes over Land: Did not explicitly address the issue of land distribution or compensation for freed slaves.
- Aim: Quick restoration of the Union with minimal social and political change.
3. Congressional Plan (also known as the Radical Reconstruction Plan):
- Key features: Enacted by the Radical Republicans in Congress, who were more focused on protecting the rights of freed slaves and ensuring long-term societal transformation.
- Military Occupation: Divided the South into military districts, placing them under military control until they ratified the 14th Amendment.
- Suffrage for African Americans: Pushed for granting voting rights to African American men.
- Protection for Freed Slaves: Enacted laws such as the Civil Rights Act of 1866 and the 15th Amendment to protect the civil rights of freed slaves.
- Land Redistribution: Supported redistribution of land to African Americans and newly freed slaves.
- Aim: Long-lasting transformation of the South by ensuring political rights and economic opportunities for freed slaves.
4. Comparisons:
- Amnesty and Pardon: Presidential Plan offered amnesty to most Confederates, while the Congressional Plan imposed military occupation and required ratification of the 14th Amendment.
- Political Rights: The Presidential Plan did not emphasize granting political rights to freed slaves, but the Congressional Plan advocated for suffrage for African American men.
- Land Distribution: The Presidential Plan did not address the issue of land distribution, while the Congressional Plan supported land redistribution to African Americans.
- Military Occupation: The Congressional Plan imposed military control over the South, unlike the Presidential Plan.
- Goals: The Presidential Plan sought a quick restoration of the Union, while the Congressional Plan focused on long-term societal transformation and protection of freed slaves' rights.
By following these steps, you can compare the presidential and congressional plans of Reconstruction. Understanding the context and key features of each plan will help you analyze their similarities and differences more effectively.
The presidential and congressional plans of Reconstruction were two distinct approaches to rebuilding the United States after the Civil War. Here is a comparison of these two plans:
Presidential Plan:
1. Proponent: The presidential plan was formulated and implemented by President Abraham Lincoln initially and later by President Andrew Johnson.
2. Goals: The main goal of the presidential plan was to quickly reintegrate the Southern states back into the Union. It aimed to restore the Union as it was before the war and promote reconciliation with the defeated Southern states.
3. Amnesty and Pardons: The plan offered a general pardon to most Southerners who took an oath of loyalty to the Union, except for high-ranking Confederate officials and military leaders.
4. Lenient Approach: The presidential plan was relatively lenient towards the South, aiming to avoid harsh punishments and facilitate a speedy reconstruction process.
5. Slavery: The plan did not specify any clear measures regarding the future of slavery, leaving the decision to individual states.
6. Limited Suffrage: The plan did not prioritize granting suffrage to freed slaves – it left this decision to the individual states, effectively allowing them to control the voting rights of African Americans.
Congressional Plan:
1. Proponent: The congressional plan was backed by the Radical Republicans in Congress, who sought to implement a more radical and transformative approach to Reconstruction.
2. Goals: The main goal of the congressional plan was to ensure the rights and protections of freed slaves and to transform the South politically, socially, and economically.
3. Military Control: The plan called for military control of the Southern states, with the establishment of military districts governed by Union generals.
4. Harsh Punishments: The plan aimed to punish the leading Confederate officials and wealthy landowners who supported the Confederacy. It often sought to confiscate their properties and redistribute them to former slaves.
5. Reconstruction Acts: The congressional plan involved passing several Reconstruction Acts that required Southern states to ratify the Fourteenth Amendment, protecting civil rights, and granting voting rights to African American men.
6. Expansion of Suffrage: The plan prioritized granting suffrage to African Americans, and it required Southern states to rewrite their constitutions to include voting rights for freed slaves.
In summary, the presidential plan focused on a quick reunification of the country, with a relatively lenient approach towards the South, while the congressional plan aimed for a more transformative and radical reconstruction, especially concerning the rights of freed slaves and the punishment of Confederate sympathizers.