Lord of the flies questions 1-7
Although it appears that Ralph and jack would become good friends strain is being placed on their friendship. The boys seem to be from two different world, "There was the brilliant world of hunting, tactics, fierce exhilaration, skill: and there was the world of longing and baffled common-sense"
TO what degree do you feel Jack is causing the break down of order on the island? Do you feel Ralph is being firm enough with Jack? What are Ralphs alternatives?
As Jack and Ralph have less and less in common, Piggy and Ralph are drawing closer and closer together. Has there been a change in either Ralph or Piggy since the beginning of the novel which might account for their becoming friendlier? In your opinion, how much do circumstances have to do with this closeness? if the boys were in England, with whom do you think Ralph would more likely become friends? Why?
These questions are asking for YOUR opinion. My ESP connection is down this evening, so I can't tell what you're thinking.
To assess the degree to which Jack is causing the breakdown of order on the island in Lord of the Flies, you can examine the actions and behavior of Jack throughout the novel. Look for instances where Jack challenges Ralph's authority, undermines the rules and order established by Ralph, or incites chaos and violence. Consider how Jack's obsession with hunting and his desire for power and control contribute to the disintegration of order.
To determine if Ralph is being firm enough with Jack, analyze Ralph's responses and actions towards Jack. Consider if Ralph is effectively asserting his leadership and making decisions that maintain order and address the conflicts arising from Jack's behavior. Assess if Ralph is able to effectively communicate and enforce rules and hold Jack accountable for his actions.
Ralph's alternatives in dealing with Jack's behavior would depend on the specific circumstances and the dynamics of the group. Some possible alternatives for Ralph could include:
1. Establishing clearer rules and consequences: Ralph could try to reinforce the rules and establish consequences for breaking them, in an effort to maintain order and discourage Jack's disruptive behavior.
2. Building a coalition: Ralph could try to rally the remaining boys who are still loyal to him and build a united front against Jack, aiming to isolate him and reduce his influence.
3. Negotiation and compromise: Ralph could attempt to find common ground with Jack and address any underlying issues that are driving his destructive behavior. This could involve offering alternatives or compromises that satisfy Jack's desire for power and control while maintaining overall order on the island.
Regarding the evolving friendship between Ralph and Piggy, consider the changes in their behavior and interactions throughout the novel. Look for instances where they support and rely on each other, share common goals, and demonstrate increased trust and understanding. It is possible that the challenging circumstances on the island, where they are both outsiders and face a common threat, have prompted them to find solace and support in each other.
In terms of the influence of circumstances on their friendship, the absence of adult supervision, the struggle for survival, and the growing tensions within the group could have undoubtedly contributed to their bonding. The shared experiences of fear, isolation, and a desire to maintain order and reason in the face of chaos could have forged a stronger connection between Ralph and Piggy.
If the boys were in England, it is difficult to speculate on whom Ralph would more likely become friends with. It would depend on the specific personalities and backgrounds of the potential friends. However, given Ralph's initial position as a popular and charismatic school prefect, it is plausible that he might gravitate towards individuals who share his leadership qualities and value reason and order in a civilized society.