statistics
posted by Anonymous .
A hypothetical HIV vaccine trial involving 20,000 participants—10,000 in the vaccine group and 10,000 in the placebo group—had the following results: 6.3 infections per 1000 in the vaccine group and 9.0 infections per 1000 in the placebo group.
I ran a computer simulation to predict possible outcomes of the trial if the null hypothesis is true—that is, if vaccinated and unvaccinated people are equally likely to contract HIV. I ran 1000 virtual trials of 20,000 people (10,000 per group) assuming that the vaccine is ineffective. Outcomes are expressed as excess infections in the placebo group. Here are the results of the 1000 virtual trials displayed as a histogram.
1. Roughly estimate the (twosided) pvalue associated with the trial’s outcome from the histogram.
2. From the simulation, I learn that the statistic ‘excess infections in the placebo group’ follows a normal distribution with a mean of 0 and a standard deviation (standard error) of 12.3. Use this information to calculate the twosided pvalue more precisely than in (11). Round to the nearest thousandth.
4. The effect size in this hypothetical trial (2.7 fewer infections per 1000 vaccinated) is slightly smaller than the effect size found in the real 2009 HIV vaccine trial (2.8 fewer infections per 1000 vaccinated); so why is the pvalue smaller?
A) The hypothetical trial has less variability.
B) The sample size of the hypothetical trial is larger.
C) The real trial did not follow a normal distribution.
D) The real trial used an intention to treat analysis.
Respond to this Question
Similar Questions

Epidemiology
Indicate how the bias would affect the measure of association. Would it be under estimated, or over estimated or unchanged. Persons diagnosed as HIV positive or negative were interviewed about their number of lifetime sexual partners. … 
Economics  Cost benefit analysis
Imagine that there are two cohorts of 100 patients each. One group got the flu vaccine and other group did not. Outcomes Vaccine Group Outcomes = 90 patients without the flu NoVaccine Group Outcomes = 50 without the flu Costs Vaccine … 
statistics
A group of adults of 200 aged 21 to 50 were selected from those entering Fit Right Health stores in Washington state, and were randomly divided into two groups. One group was given an herb and the othe placebo. After 6 months, the … 
statistics
Surgery vs. placebo for the knee pain: Refer to Example 10. Is Arthroscopic Surgery Better than Placebo? 
Psychology
A psychologist is performing an experiment involving a controlled group and an experimental group. With the experimental group, the psychologist is giving a placebo and labeling it as caffeine pill. The control group receives a caffeine … 
Can someone help with this?
A psychologist is performing an experiment involving a controlled group and an experimental group. With the experimental group, the psychologist is giving a placebo and labeling it as caffeine pill. The control group receives a caffeine … 
Statistics
The effect size in this hypothetical trial (2.7 fewer infections per 1000 vaccinated) is slightly smaller than the effect size found in the real 2009 HIV vaccine trial (2.8 fewer infections per 1000 vaccinated); so why is the pvalue … 
Psychology
What is the independent and dependent variable in this scenario: A Physiological Psychologist is interested in investigating the effects of a new antianxiety drug on maze running behaviour in rats. A pool of rats is divided into two … 
statisticsbob
Perform a oneway ANOVA analysis, testing at the 0.05 level. Also, calculate the mean number of sick days for each group. Describe your results. But equally important, also explain what you would do if you owned your own company. Would … 
math
Several studies have been conduct on the effectiveness and safety of the H1N1 influenza vaccine. One study found that in a group that received the actual medication, the drug was 87% effective. In a group that received a placebo, there …