Some readers argue that the adults in this play-- Friar Lawrence and Juliet's nurce--- do an incredibly BAD job of mentoring and providing guidance to romeo and juliet; in fact, some people believe that without these meddling adults, Romeo and Juliet would not end in the way it does. Give your opinion about these adults-- are they good role models, or do they fail Romeo and Juliet. Please use quotes to justify your opinion.
Once you write up YOUR OPINION about this topic, please post it, and someone here will be happy to critique your thinking.
To form an opinion on whether the adults in Romeo and Juliet are good role models or whether they failed Romeo and Juliet, we need to analyze their actions and guidance throughout the play. Here are some steps to help you come up with your own opinion:
1. Read and analyze the play: Begin by reading or reviewing the play, paying close attention to the interactions and guidance provided by Friar Lawrence and Juliet's nurse.
2. Identify instances of their guidance: Look for moments where Friar Lawrence and the nurse provide advice or guidance to Romeo and Juliet. Take note of the context and how it affects the outcome of events.
3. Evaluate their influence on Romeo and Juliet's choices: Consider how their advice influenced the decisions made by the young couple. Did their guidance contribute to the tragic ending, or did it attempt to prevent it?
4. Assess their intentions: Evaluate the motivations behind the actions of each character. Did they genuinely have Romeo and Juliet's best interests at heart, or were they driven by their own personal agendas?
5. Review supporting quotes: Once you have analyzed the play, find quotes that support your opinion. Look for instances where the adults' actions or advice either positively or negatively impacted Romeo and Juliet.
For example, you could argue that Friar Lawrence and the nurse provided guidance that ultimately led to the tragedy. One quote that supports this argument is when Friar Lawrence gives Romeo the idea of faking Juliet's death: "Shall Romeo by my letters know our drift, / And hither shall he come; and he and I / Will watch thy waking, and that very night / Shall Romeo bear thee hence to Mantua" (Act 4, Scene 1). This guidance leads to a chain of events that results in misunderstandings and ultimately the deaths of both Romeo and Juliet.
On the other hand, you could argue that their intentions were noble and that they genuinely tried to help Romeo and Juliet. For example, the nurse was Juliet's confidante and provided emotional support: "Go, girl, seek happy nights to happy days" (Act 3, Scene 2). This shows that she cared about Juliet's happiness.
By following these steps and utilizing quotes from the play, you will be able to form your own opinion about whether the adults in Romeo and Juliet were good role models or failed Romeo and Juliet.