math
posted by sally .
My son has been given the collinear problem below that has be stumped two folds.
1 By trying to solve the problem using (y2y1)/(x2x1)=slope  and then, find the (b) in y=mx+b for two points takes way way too long to be a 7th grade probem. My son has already been working on it for over two hours. There must be a shortcut…
2 Why is it that; y=mx+b for points with a zero never give the righ b? e.g. (0,3)
Problem:
The coordinates of the points are:
A= (0,3)  B=(2.11)  C=(3,3)  D=(1,9)  E=(3,10) F=(6,10)  G=(5,19)  H=(6,18)
Three, and only three of these points are collinear. The student’s task is to determine “Analytically” and without plotting, which three is the collinear trio.

sorry B=(2,11)

I agree with you that this is a rather ridiculous question
There are 21 possible pairs of points, each pair could give us the equation of a line containing such a pair.
If the objective is to use the method you suggest, it could just as easily be effictive with , let's say, 4 points.
I would have allowed my students to make a sketch, thus eliminating some of the more obvious noncollinear points.
You don't actually have to find the equation of the line. If you find the slopes of pairs that have a common point, and those two slopes are equal, then the 3 points are collinear.
e.g. If slope PQ = slope PR , the P, Q, and R are collinear, notice P was the "link"
but, if slope PQ = slope RS, all we know is that PQ  RS
As to your point #2, I think you must be making some kind of error,
Using a point such as (0,3) in y=mx +b will let you find b in the same way as using any other point
e.g. suppose we know y = 4x + b and we are told that (0,3) is on it
3 = 4(0) + b
b = 3
notice that in y = mx + b, the b value is the yinercept
and of course (0,3) is the point of the yintercept, so obviously if in a point, the x = 0, the y must be the value of b in the equation. 
I played with this for a while but could see no practical way to do it without sketching the points.
I dis put the points in order of increasing x from 6 to +6 which makes it easier to visualize 
Thank you very much Reiny and also Damon. This is the first time I felt embarrassed helping my son. Sign of things to come of course. As Reiny suggested, we ended up plotting and then selecting less than half a dozen candidates. I also cheated and made a spreadsheet just to speed things up. The spreadsheet quickly showed the Trio is: C, H AND F.
Thank you again
Respond to this Question
Similar Questions

Math help plz
How thick is a pile of paper? Find a relationship between the number of folds and the number of layers. Note your observations. Number of folds Number of layers 0 1 1 2 2 4 3 8 4 14 5 23 Plz help im so stuck on this question Are you 
Algebra
Given a line containing the points(1,4), (2,7) and (3,10) determine that slopeintercept form of the equation, provide one additional point on this line, and graph the funtion. Start by putting the first point into pointslope form: … 
Math Help
Directions are that i have to solve the equation and graph it using words.I have to include whether itis a solid or dotted line and which way the shading is. Problem: 2x+3y<6 dotted line. There is no equals in the problem. Which … 
Math
On a grid with points R(2,6)& S(3,4), what is the slope of line RS? 
Algebra 2
I know that were doing problems were there is a soultion given which is equal to X^? 
Mathematics
I need to solve this problem in two diferent ways showing work. I have one way but I don't know what the other way could be the problem is 3 3/4 +5 1/3 
Math
I haven't done factoring in ages I'm trying to factor this X^2  2X + 8 If i remeber correctly sense the leading coefficent is 1 the factored form is in this format (XA)(XB) which would give you X^2 AX  Bx + AB or simply X^2 (A+B)X … 
math 118
a. Suppose a market research company finds that at a price of p = $6., they would sell x = 44 tiles each month. If they lower the price to p = $2, then more people would purchase the tile, and they can expect to sell x = 48 tiles in … 
Algebra
Please help me to solve this problem. Thank you in advance for helping to solve this problem. Have a great day. Here is the question? 
Math
Two collinear points are given in the table, give a third point that is also on this line x 0 4. It is written vertically on a graph, the other side states y 0 3. I do not understand how to find the third point for each problem. I …