Post a New Question

english

posted by .

did i use the comma rule correctly?
The oil from Eucalyptus trees which are native, to Australia is known for its medicinal properties.

  • english -

    Nope, try

    The oil from Eucalyptus trees, which are native to Australia, is known for its medicinal properties.

    The oil is known for its properties.

    "which are native to Australia" describes the trees, but is not necessary to convey any meaning about the oil.

    Now, if there are trees under discussion which are not native to Australia, then the first comma needs to be deleted, since the only trees of interest are those not native to Australia. Just as if you say

    The boy who is tall has red hair.

    That implies that there are other boys who are not tall.

    however,

    The boy, who is tall, has red hair.

    means that the boy has red hair, but by the way, he is also tall. Nice to know, but not necessary.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. english

    Select the sentence that is punctuated correctly. (Points : 1) The oil from Eucalyptus trees which are native, to Australia is known for its medicinal properties. The oil from Eucalyptus trees, which are native to Australia, is known …
  2. english

    Select the sentence that is punctuated correctly. (Points : 1) The oil from Eucalyptus trees which are native, to Australia is known for its medicinal properties. The oil from Eucalyptus trees, which are native to Australia, is known …
  3. grammar

    Is this sentence punctuated correctly? The oil from Eucalyptus trees, which are native to Australia, is known for its medicinal properties.
  4. english

    select the sentence that is punctuated correctly. The oil from Eucalyptus trees which are native, to Australia is known for its medicinal properties. The oil from Eucalyptus trees, which are native to Australia, is known for its medicinal …
  5. english

    Select the sentence that is punctuated correctly. The oil from Eucalyptus trees which are native, to Australia is known for its medicinal properties. The oil from Eucalyptus trees, which are native to Australia, is known for its medicinal …
  6. Punctuation

    Is this correct? Even though it is almost summer, we still have overcast skies and light rain. The neighbors’ new dog is, small, quiet and shy. The oil from Eucalyptus trees, which are native to Australia, is known for its medicinal
  7. where do you place the comas

    The oil from Eucalyptus trees which are native to Australia is known for its medicinal properties
  8. mesqite high school

    Is this sentence punctuated correctly? The oil from Eucalyptus trees which are native, to Australia is known for its medicinal properties
  9. Science

    Koalas, which are native to Australia, primarily eat the leaves of the eucalyptus trees in which they live. Which of the following would happen to koalas if people destroy their habitats in order to build houses?
  10. exp 105

    Question 2. 2. Select the sentence that is punctuated correctly. (Points : 1) The oil from Eucalyptus trees which are native, to Australia is known for its medicinal properties. The oil from Eucalyptus trees, which are native to Australia, …

More Similar Questions

Post a New Question