What are the advantages and disadvantages of using wet mount preparation instead of stained specimens to observe microorganism?
Since Jiskha doesn't have a biology expert at this time, please try posting your question at this site.
http://www.biology-online.org/biology-forum/
thanks :)
You're welcome.
=)
To compare the advantages and disadvantages of using wet mount preparations and stained specimens to observe microorganisms, let's first explain how to create each type of specimen and then discuss their characteristics.
1. Wet Mount Preparations:
To create a wet mount preparation, follow these steps:
a. Take a clean microscope slide and place a drop of liquid containing the microorganisms on it.
b. Gently place a coverslip over the drop, taking care to avoid trapping air bubbles.
Advantages of Wet Mount Preparation:
1. Real-time observation: Wet mount preparations allow for the immediate observation of living microorganisms. This enables the study of their dynamic movements, patterns, and behaviors.
2. Preservation of natural characteristics: Microorganisms in wet mount preparations retain their original shapes, sizes, and colors because they are not subjected to fixation or staining procedures.
3. Minimal sample processing: Wet mount preparations involve minimal sample preparation, making them quick and convenient to create.
Disadvantages of Wet Mount Preparation:
1. Low contrast: The lack of staining in wet mount preparations can make it difficult to distinguish the microorganisms from their surroundings. This is especially true if the microbes are transparent or have similar refractive indices as the surrounding medium.
2. Short observation time: Wet mounts tend to dry out relatively quickly, limiting the duration of observation. This can make it challenging to study slower processes or conduct detailed examinations.
2. Stained Specimens:
To create stained specimens, various staining techniques can be employed, such as gram staining, acid-fast staining, or simple stains like crystal violet or methylene blue.
Advantages of Stained Specimens:
1. Improved contrast: Staining microorganisms increases the contrast between the organisms and their environment, making them easier to identify and study under a microscope.
2. Better visibility of cellular structures: Stains can selectively highlight specific cellular structures, such as cell walls, nuclei, or flagella. This enables detailed examination and identification of different microbial components.
3. Longer observation time: Stained specimens, once prepared, can be stored and observed for a longer duration compared to wet mounts. This allows for a more comprehensive analysis and documentation.
Disadvantages of Stained Specimens:
1. Artifacts: The staining process can introduce artifacts that alter the appearance of microorganisms, potentially affecting their natural characteristics and making them less representative of their live state.
2. Killing of microorganisms: Many staining techniques involve fixation, which kills the microorganisms. This eliminates the possibility of studying their living behavior and dynamics.
3. Time-consuming and complex procedure: Staining specimens requires multiple steps and can be time-consuming. Additionally, different staining techniques have varying requirements and complexities.
In summary, wet mount preparations provide immediate observation of live microorganisms with minimal processing, while stained specimens offer improved visibility and longer observation times but may alter the organisms and involve more time and effort for preparation. The choice between the two methods depends on the specific research objectives and the need for real-time observation or detailed examination.