posted by Henry2

Writeacher, where shall I "who"instead of which" in the sentence below? Thank you.

1) In all revenge tragedies a sexual or violent crime is committed against a family member of the hero, which (stands for the "crime") for various reasons cannot be punished; so even though the hero seeks revenge for this crime, he usually goes through a period of doubt which (a period of doubts) will involve complex planning.

  1. Writeacher

    The verb "punish" is not used for crimes, but for people. People are punished ... or not ... for their crimes.

    This makes sense:

    In all revenge tragedies, a sexual or violent crime is committed against a hero's family member, who cannot be punished for various reasons; so even though the hero seeks revenge for this crime, he usually goes through a period of doubt which will involve complex planning.

    Modifiers (adjective/adverbial clauses, participial phrases, adjectives, adverbs, etc.) need to be placed as close as possible (preferably right next to) whatever it's modifying or referring to.
    Read about all of them -- misplaced, dangling ...

    I rarely had this problem when I was studying and writing in Latin -- all the cases and number and gender endings took care of identifying the antecedent clearly. However, English doesn't have all those endings, so word order has to solve the problem of misplaced/dangling modifiers!

Respond to this Question

First Name

Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. English

    I forgot to include the following sentences. Thank you very much for your help! 1)The revenge tragedy (or a revenge tragedy) has the following features. First of all, a sexual or violent crime is committed (has been committed is possible?
  2. English

    Thank you. Here are other statements I urgently need you to check. 1) How does Hamlet regard courage and cowardice respectively?
  3. English

    As to my previous post, I thought I could use the infinitive with to if the action was perceived from the beginning to the end (I was seen to steal the watch/ Active: He saw me steal the watch). I'm finding it difficult to check these …
  4. English

    Thank you very much for your corrections! Here are some more sentences I need you to revise. 1)There is the appearance of a ghost which urges the hero to commit the revenge. (Correction: to avenge, get/have/take revenge on Claudius/to …
  5. English

    I left out a few sentences. I hope you can have a look at them too 1) The play finishes with the killing of the King, Hamlet,Queen Gerturde and Laertes. 2) According to the medieval perspective the body is the prison of our mind. 3) …
  6. English

    Could you please check this paragraph I varied on the tragedy of revenge?
  7. English

    I left out the following sentences, thank yoU, Writeacher. 1) She tells him to wash his bloody hands with water. 2) The main characteristics of a revenge tragedy are as follows. First, a violent or sexual crime is committed against …
  8. English

    I did some of the corrections myself. I find it really hard to check all the grammar mistakes. Could you please help me, Writeacher?
  9. English

    I left out the following sentences. I did some corrections myself. I hope you can help me. Thank you very much. 1)All revenge tragedies derive from the Greeks, then came Seneca who set the rules for all revenge tragedies written in …
  10. English

    Thank you, Writeacher. I left out these other sentences. Can you please check them?

More Similar Questions