psy326

posted by .

If a question must be answered that has significant negative psychological impact on the subject, such as in the Stanford prison study, is it more ethical to use human or animal subjects?

  • psy326 -

    Answered last night:

    http://www.jiskha.com/display.cgi?id=1326854705

  • psy326 -

    It depends on whose ethics you are using. The value of the knowledge gained from the study needs to be balanced with the potential harm to the subjects. Animal lovers might disagree with Ms.Sue's response, seeing many studies as animal cruelty.

    Also, I doubt if you could get any results from animals that could simulate the responses of humans in Zimbardo's Stanford Prison Study.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. ethics

    How do the unique relationship between human service organizations and the populations they serve impact ethical decisions?
  2. English

    1. There are a lot of clubs in my school. 2. There are a lot of clubs in our school. (Are both correct?
  3. English

    1.the subject of the sentence is first person, then the verb must be in what form?
  4. psych

    Discuss ethical issues in psychology, including the use of animal subjects, confidentiality, informed consent, and the use of deception in research. Describe how psychologists' values influence their work.
  5. Causal Argument Paper

    Hello, I am needing help formulating a question for my English class. We are needing to write an ethical/causal argument. I want to relate it to either animal testing or animal hunting. Is this a decent one?
  6. psy326

    The need for increasing oversight in psychological research is changing as demand for ethical practices and complexities of research are challenged. Present an overview, based on your readings and outside research, of this phenomenon. …
  7. human services

    I need help on answering this question and where I can find the answer. please help. Briefly discuss each of the ethical standards and the following general principles: · The use of psychological tests in the courtroom · The lie …
  8. psy 326

    If a question must be answered that has significant negative psychological impact on the subject, such as in the Stanford prison study, is it more ethical to use human or animal subjects?
  9. Statistics

    In a study of pleas and prison sentences, it is found that 40% of the subjects studied were sent to prison. Among those sent to prison, 20% chose to plead guilty. Among those not sent to prison, 10% chose to plead guilty. 3.3.a (0.5 …
  10. Conference

    Your assignment is to review the case study starting on page 150, “Closer Look: The Stanford Prison Study.” Write a paper answering the following questions: • Considering the effects this experiment had on its subjects, do you …

More Similar Questions