Hi, I have to write up paragraphs on these themes from Frankenstein:

a) good vs. evil (manichean)
b) duty of responsibility
c) nature vs. nurture

However, I'm confused about what the differences between these points are...

For example, in "nature vs. nurture", wouldn't you talk about how the monster was rejected by society and hence turned evil? But doesn't this fall under "duty of responsibility", as well as the evil part of "good versus evil"?

Thanks for your help!

Nature vs. nurture and

good vs. evil are two different pairs of categories entirely. The former refers to two different explanations of personality development.

Be sure you read all of the following carefully BEFORE you start planning what you will write:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nature_versus_nurture

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_and_evil

http://www.marshasummers.com/innerman/duty.htm
and
http://www.personal-development.com/chuck/duty.htm

I understand your confusion, as there can be some overlap between these themes in Frankenstein. Let's break down each theme and discuss their differences and connections.

a) Good vs. Evil (Manichean): This theme explores the dichotomy between good and evil in the novel. In Frankenstein, you can analyze the contrasting nature of Dr. Frankenstein and his creation, the Monster. Consider how Frankenstein's ambition and pursuit of knowledge without regard for ethical boundaries lead to disastrous consequences. On the other hand, you can examine the Monster's actions and motivations which, despite initially being driven by loneliness and societal rejection, turn towards acts of vengeance and malevolence.

b) Duty of Responsibility: This theme focuses on the moral obligation and accountability that characters have towards their actions and creations. Dr. Frankenstein neglects his responsibility to care for and guide his creation, which ultimately leads to the Monster's descent into evil. Additionally, you can analyze the consequences of Frankenstein's abandonment of his duty to his family and friends, as his relentless pursuit of scientific discovery takes precedence over his responsibilities towards them.

c) Nature vs. Nurture: This theme explores the extent to which a person's behavior and actions are influenced by their inherent nature or their upbringing and environment. In Frankenstein, you can discuss how the Monster's initial benevolent nature is corrupted by the rejection and mistreatment he faces from society. However, it also raises questions about the responsibility of society in shaping individuals and nurturing their potential for good. You can examine the role of nurture in Frankenstein's own development, for example, how his early experiences and education influence his choices and actions.

While there may be some overlap between these themes, it's important to focus on the specific aspects and implications of each theme. For example, when discussing the Monster's transformation into evil, you can integrate elements of both "Nature vs. Nurture" and "Good vs. Evil." However, when analyzing the theme of "Duty of Responsibility," you can explore Frankenstein's neglect of his creation as a separate aspect.

To write your paragraphs, you can start by introducing the theme and provide a brief overview of its significance in the novel. Then delve into specific examples or events from the story that highlight that particular theme and its relevance. These examples will vary depending on the theme you're discussing. Finally, conclude your paragraphs by reflecting on the broader implications of the theme and its impact on the story.