English

posted by .

According to the first philosophers, did they think of rhetoric as good or negative?
I know that Aristotle thought of it more good because it wasn't just used for politics, but for much more. Plato looked on it more negatively because it could easily manipulate people and a form of deceit. I am not sure what the overall answer would be. Because some thought of it as negative others positive.

  • English -

    see the wiki article, it is an excellent summary.

    Search WIKI Greek retoric http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhetoric#History

  • English -

    So the first philosophers thought rhetoric was good right ?

  • English -

    "Good"? I don't know what good means.
    Classical Greeks felt rhetoric, or the power to speak before an audience was essential and useful.

    <<In ancient Greece, the earliest mention of oratorical skill occurs in Homer's Iliad, where heroes like Achilles, Hektor, and Odysseus were honored for their ability to advise and exhort their peers and followers (the Laos or army) in wise and appropriate action. With the rise of the democratic polis, speaking skill was adapted to the needs of the public and political life of cities in ancient Greece, much of which revolved around the use of oratory as the medium through which political and judicial decisions were made, and through which philosophical ideas were developed and disseminated. For modern students today, it can be difficult to remember that the wide use and availability of written texts is a phenomenon that was just coming into vogue in Classical Greece. In Classical times, many of the great thinkers and political leaders performed their works before an audience, usually in the context of a competition or contest for fame, political influence, and cultural capital; in fact, many of them are known only through the texts that their students, followers, or detractors wrote down. As has already been noted, rhetor was the Greek term for orator: A rhetor was a citizen who regularly addressed juries and political assemblies and who was thus understood to have gained some knowledge about public speaking in the process, though in general facility with language was often referred to as logôn techne, "skill with arguments" or "verbal artistry."[42]>>

  • English -

    Well then they looked at it as a positive aspect. Right?

  • English -

    YEs, in ancient and classical Greeks toolkits, rhetoric was how they did it. Your thoughts on Plato of the later period, are valid.

  • English -

    Oh ok i understand. Thank you very much :))

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. Grammar

    I was wondering if you can help me correct these following sentences: focus is on glossary usage. 1. Due to Plato's preoccupation with shadowy forms, Aristotle was aggravated enought ot leave The Academy and bring his followers along …
  2. Writing/ New York Times

    i just read in the Editorial Section of the New York Times about Uinted States Losing the Good War.. You know where i can find more information on this?
  3. college philosophy

    According to Plato what makes something essentially good?
  4. ms. sue pls. help me urgent

    pls help me if my english is correct in grammar or relevant to the question thank you. question..1.What is meant by “if we are to improve our speaking skills, we must first become more aware of ourselves, our motivation, behavior …
  5. English grammar checking

    Hi; Just wondering if my grammar looks good.:) Some people find fables to be a negative thing because they are clearer then what they would actually be in reality. Like they teach children that the good always win or gain the good …
  6. english grammar checking

    Hi; Just wondering if my grammar looks good.:) Some people find fables to be a negative thing because they are clearer then what they would actually be in reality. Like they teach children that the good always win or gain the good …
  7. History

    Plato and Aristotle both argued that political life should reflect humans' aspirations to live in a genuinely "good" society. However, their visions and ideas were very distinct. How were these "good societies" similar, and how were …
  8. World History Answer Check

    1. Explain how the Code of Hammurabi influences politcal thought. A: The Code of Hammurabi influenced political thought because it was the first written code of law ever created. It was a very effective way to keep order and prevent …
  9. World History Answer Check

    1. How did the governments favored by Plato and Aristotle differ?
  10. English

    What would be a good thesis statement for a research paper on endangered species I'm trying to focus more on the overall history such as why we created the endangered species list in the first place I just can't think of a good thesis …

More Similar Questions