Is eye color a discontinuous or continuous variation? Why is everyone saying that it's a discontinuous variation, when you obviously have a gradation of different colors around the world in the human population, and it's a polygenic trait determined by many genes! So shouldn't it be a continuous variation, just like hair color and skin color?

Eye color is generally considered a discontinuous variation, although it does have a continuous distribution due to the multiple genes involved. The terms "discontinuous" and "continuous" refer to different aspects of a variation.

Discontinuous variation refers to distinct categories or phenotypes that can be easily classified into separate groups. For example, in the case of eye color, common categories include blue, green, brown, hazel, and gray. These categories can be easily identified, and individuals usually fall into one of these distinct groups.

On the other hand, continuous variation refers to a range of phenotypic values that do not have clear-cut categories, allowing for a gradual gradation between different forms. Traits like height and weight are classic examples of continuous variation since they can take on a wide range of values, without discrete categories to separate individuals.

While eye color does exhibit a continuous distribution due to the involvement of multiple genes, it is usually considered discontinuous because individuals are often categorized into distinct color groups. Additionally, despite the multiple genes influencing eye color, the variation within each category (e.g., different shades of blue or brown) is relatively small compared to the overall distinction between categories.

It is worth noting that the classification of traits can sometimes be subjective, and opinions may vary among scientists. Some sources might classify eye color as a continuous variation due to the wide range of colors observed. However, the more common classification is as a discontinuous variation, based on the easily distinguishable categories and the robustness of the primary colors (blue, green, and brown) as distinct groups in most human populations.

Eye color can be considered as both a continuous and discontinuous variation, depending on the context and perspective. Let's break it down to understand why there might be differing opinions on this matter.

First, it's important to note that eye color is influenced by multiple genes, as well as environmental factors. This makes it a polygenic trait, meaning that it is determined by the combined effect of several genes. The levels of expression of these genes can lead to variations in eye color, resulting in a gradation of different colors observed around the world. In this sense, eye color shows some aspects of continuous variation.

However, when we talk about discontinuous variation, we usually refer to traits that are expressed in distinct categories or discrete groups. For example, blood types or flower colors that occur in well-defined, non-overlapping categories. In that sense, eye color can also be seen as discontinuous because it is traditionally categorized into distinct groups, such as blue, green, brown, or hazel.

Despite this categorization, the perception of eye color as a discontinuous trait is somewhat oversimplified. There is actually a spectrum of color due to the blending of different pigments and variations in the amount of melanin in the iris. Moreover, intermediate colors and variations exist, making it difficult to clearly differentiate between categories. This blending and overlapping of colors contribute to the perception of eye color as a continuous variation.

So, in conclusion, while eye color is commonly discussed as a discontinuous variation due to its categorization into distinct color groups, it also exhibits characteristics of continuous variation due to the gradation and variations observed among individuals.

I have already tried the links. none of them was of any help.

Since Jiskha does not have a regular biology tutor, you might try this site.

http://biology-forums.com/index.php

If there is a tutor here who can help you with this particular question, I'm sure he/she will add a response.