I have a question and would appreciate any input or advice
We just finished reading The Catcher in the Rye" and I'm stuck on a question for homework;
Holden's anger over Stadlater dationg Jane, who symbolically guards her kings in a game of checkers shows his strong desire to :
protect people he feels are innocent and vulnerable
have Jane for himself
be in control of every situation
expose the phony people
I'm leaning towards protecting people he feels are innocent, however, throughout the book, it indicates maybe he has feelings for Jane and made out with her, etc at one point
I'd be interested in a second opinion-please don't just direct me to sites-I've done that and still not sure which way to go-I did read the entire book so I'm not trying to cheat but just stuck--thank you
I understand your dilemma and I'd be happy to provide some guidance. Analyzing a character's motivations can be subjective, as different readers may interpret things differently. However, I can offer you some insights to help you form your own opinion.
When answering this question, it's essential to consider the evidence presented in the book and analyze Holden's actions and thoughts regarding Jane and Stradlater. Firstly, remember that Holden has known Jane for a long time and has deep feelings for her. It is evident that Holden harbors some romantic feelings for Jane, as indicated by his reminiscences and affectionate memories of her.
However, it doesn't necessarily mean that Holden's primary desire is to have Jane for himself. Throughout the novel, Holden displays a protective nature towards people he perceives as vulnerable and innocent. This is apparent in his interactions with his younger sister Phoebe and his portrayal of Jane. Holden also despises those he views as "phonies" and wants to protect these innocent figures from their influence.
Consider the symbolism of the checkerboard game as well. Holden sees himself as the "catcher in the rye," trying to catch children before they fall off the edge of a cliff, metaphorically representing losing their innocence. In this interpretation, Stadlater is portrayed as a potentially negative influence on Jane, symbolized by his symbolic guards in the game of checkers. This viewpoint aligns with the idea of Holden's strong desire to protect people he feels are innocent and vulnerable, including Jane.
To summarize, both protecting people he feels are innocent and vulnerable and having Jane for himself are potential interpretations of Holden's motivations. However, based on the evidence and themes presented in the novel, it seems more plausible to argue that Holden's anger towards Stradlater dating Jane is rooted in his desire to protect her and other vulnerable individuals rather than possessiveness.
Remember, literature analysis often encourages interpretation and different viewpoints. It's important to support your opinion with evidence from the text and explanations of why you interpret it that way.