I'm doing an essay about the 4 purposes of prison and how they are being met in the movie "The Shawshank Redemption". I have to do 4 of the 6 paragraphs with 2 points, 2 proofs, and 2 analysis.
The paragraphs that I'm doing now are about protection and deterrence.
My two points about protection are:
There is a presence of poor protection in the movie, as Tommy gets shot and killed by Captain Hadley after trying to escape.
Another example of good and bad protection is that the prison guards had protected Andy from the "Sisters"
after they were assualting him.
I can't remember or think what to write for the proof and analysis.
To provide proof and analysis for your points about protection in "The Shawshank Redemption," consider the following:
Proof for the first point:
You can provide proof for the lack of protection in the movie by referring to the specific scenes where Tommy attempts to escape and is subsequently shot and killed by Captain Hadley. You can describe how this incident highlights the failure of the prison system to adequately protect its inmates, leading to a tragic and avoidable death.
Analysis for the first point:
For the analysis, you can delve into the implications of Tommy's death in terms of the prison's duty to provide protection. You can discuss how this incident showcases a lack of security measures, such as proper training for the guards or adequate surveillance systems, which ultimately undermine the prison's ability to fulfill its purpose of protecting inmates. Additionally, you can talk about the impact of this incident on the other prisoners, emphasizing the fear, vulnerability, and sense of injustice experienced within the prison environment.
Proof for the second point:
To provide proof for the second point, you can highlight the specific scenes where the prison guards intervene to protect Andy from the "Sisters" during an assault. Discuss how these instances exemplify the prison system's capacity for providing protection to inmates in certain situations.
Analysis for the second point:
For the analysis, you can explore the significance of these instances of protection in terms of the prison's effectiveness in fulfilling its purpose. Analyze the motivations and actions of the prison guards during these situations, addressing whether their interventions are primarily driven by a sense of duty or their personal biases. Furthermore, discuss the implications of these acts of protection for Andy, including the impact on his well-being, relationships with both fellow inmates and guards, and how it shapes his overall experience within the prison.
Remember to expand on these points, provide additional evidence from the movie, and offer your insights for a comprehensive analysis of the purposes of protection within "The Shawshank Redemption."