math

posted by .

While investigating the properties of parallelograms using a dynamic
geometry software program, a student notices that the diagonals of a
parallelogram seem to bisect each other. The student conjectures
that this statement is true for all parallelograms. Which of the
following would be the most reasonable next step for the student to
take to evaluate the validity of this conjecture? My chooses are as followed.
A. Try to find more examples supporting the conjecture.
B. Try to find a counterexample to the conjecture.
C. Try to prove the conjecture using mathematical induction.
D. Try to generalize the conjecture to apply to other
quadrilaterals.

  • math -

    To evaluate the validity of a conjecture would require one of the following:
    1. Mathematically prove that the conjecture is correct,
    2. provide a counter-example to prove that the conjecture is incorrect.

    The first case applies to believers, and the second to non-believers.

    More examples do not provide mathematical proof, for example:
    Conjecture:
    "(2^p)-1 is prime if p is prime".
    Examples:
    2^2-1=3 (prime)
    2^3-1=7 (prime)
    More examples:
    2^5-1=31 (prime)
    2^7-1=127 (prime)
    BUT:
    2^11-1=2047 = 23*89
    Even though more examples do not prove the conjecture, there are merits of taking this option. In the search for more examples, perhaps the student will come across counter-examples, in which case the conjecture will be proven invalid.
    (read more about Mersene primes here:
    (Broken Link Removed)

    Mathematical induction applies very well in number theory where we can establish a proof based on known examples that are discrete, or in steps such as integers. To me, this particular problem requires a geometric proof.

    Generalizing the conjecture would require that the conjecture is established (or proved) for the case of parallelograms.

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. math HELP

    for each pair of similar parallelograms,fid the ratio of two adjacent side lengths in one parallelogram and compare it to the ratio of the corresponding side lengthes in the other parallelogram. What are they wanting me to do?
  2. Math HELP!!!

    If two parallelograms are similar,what do you know about the ratios of the two side lengths within one parallelogram and the ratios of the corresponding side lengths in the other parallelogram?
  3. Geometry

    I had to fill out a chart stating the properties of certine shapes(parallelograms). Some of them i put to many properties please tell me witch ones i have wrong. The properties to select from: 1-Opposite sides are parallel (both pair) …
  4. Geometry

    I had to fill out a chart stating the properties of certine shapes(parallelograms). Some of them i put to many properties please tell me witch ones i have wrong. There are wrong properties listed for some shapes because My teacher …
  5. math

    . Two groups of students are using a dynamic geometry software program to investigate the properties of quadrilaterals. The first group has concluded that the diagonals of a quadrilateral always bisect each other. The second group …
  6. logic

    a student is using a geometry program to investigate the midsegments of a triangle. the student uses the program to draw triangle ABC, bisect the sides of the triangle, and draw segments connecting the midpoints to form triangle KLM. …
  7. Math

    Sandi counted all the parallelograms of any size she could find in the design below how many parallelograms are there in all
  8. Math

    Which term best completes this statement?
  9. geometry (check my answers)

    determine whether the following statements are true or false: 1. all squares are rectangles false 2. all squares are parallelograms false 3. all rectangles are parallelograms true 4. all squares are rhombuses true 5. all rhombuses …
  10. language

    which statement is a true statement? A) a trapizoid is a regular polygon B) not all rectangels are parallelograms. C)not all parallelograms are rectangles. D) a trapezoid is a parallelogram. dont send me links or anything just help

More Similar Questions