posted by .

What are some problems with the following research study and how can I improve them?

A researcher is interested in testing whether violent films make people more
aggressive (the hypothesis). He asks his research assistants to wait outside the
Friday night showing of Die Cheerleader Die! and ask for volunteers to fill out
a questionnaire. Willing participants complete a scale of aggressive feelings,
including questions such as, “ How aggressive do you feel right now?” and “ If someone challenged you to a fistfight, how likely would you be to accept the challenge?” After compiling the scores of 100 volunteers, the researcher finds that, on average, respondents scored very high on the scale. He concludes that violent films do, in fact, make people more aggressive, and when they don’ t, it still doesn’ t invalidate this hypothesis because people are just in denial about their aggressive urges. He immediately calls a press conference to announce his findings and to say that he’ll be talking about them on the Oprah show.


  • Psychology -

    First, the volunteers are self-selecting. Did those who volunteered experience more aggression than those who didn't volunteer?

    Are people who are prone to aggression more likely to attend such a film?

    How can you measure how they felt before seeing the film?

  • Psychology -

    Also, where is the control group?

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. maths

    number of films seen by a group of people during the past year No of films seen 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 No of people 23 12 9 6 3 4 2 0 1 What percentage of people had seen more than 4 films during the year?
  2. Statistics

    What does it mean when a researcher chooses the cutoff in a comparison distribution to be .01?
  3. psych

    15. Discuss the following hypothetical pieces of research and point out the problems with the research design which prevent you from drawing the stated conclusions.  In addition, suggest at least two factors other than the one mentioned …
  4. psychology

    A researcher predicts that listening to music while solving math problems will make a particular brain area more active. To test this, a research participant has her brain scanned while listening to music and solving math problems, …
  5. PSY315

    Based on the information given for each of the following studies, decide whether to reject the null hypothesis. For each, give (a) the Z-score cutoff (or cutoffs) on the comparison distribution at which the null hypothesis should be …
  6. Research

    I would like to have your input on the following questions. (1) Why is students study habits worth a study for a research proposal?
  7. psychology

    Hi I need help with my homework, I wrote down my answers, just need you to check if their right. Thanks 1. which of the following is not a goal of psychology?
  8. psychology

    A hypothesis is what an investigator uses to: duplicate research findings of other scientists. frame his/her research question. explain why he/she obtained a certain result from an experiment. define the parameters of a research study. …
  9. intro to psychology

    A researcher is studying people of normal weight and obese individuals. She wants to know how the time of day affects hunger feelings in these two groups. When, during the experiment, the researcher looks at her watch, she has introduced …
  10. Psychology Stats and Research

    Although there is a popular belief that herbal remedies such as Ginkgo biloba and Ginseng may improve learning and memory in healthy adults, these effects are usually not supported by well-controlled research (Persson, Bringlov, Nilsson, …

More Similar Questions