How Would One Discuss This Topic:
Japan controlled neighbors because it could. Japan also took over Korea and China because it needed land and resources. Japan is an island country, therefore, it needed a dependable source of raw materials. This is usually true of imperialist countries: they want raw materials from their colonies.
SORRY THIS IS THE TOPIC I DO NOT UNDERSTAND (THE FIRST POST IS MY ANSWER:
Under what circumstances (if any) should one country in a region have the right to control other nations in the region? (Consider the principal reasons for Japanese imperialism)’
Suppose Canada or Mexico wanted to control the United States. Under what circumstances would you agree to being taken over by either of these countries?
In your answer, you said that Japan NEEDED land and resources. It WANTED them, but you can't say it NEEDED them. If I steal your ipod or other gadget, would you feel ok if I told you I needed it?
To discuss the topic of Japan controlling its neighbors, particularly Korea and China, it is important to understand the historical context of Japan's expansionist policies in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Here are some steps to consider when discussing this topic:
1. Research the historical background: Start by researching the historical events and factors that led to Japan's expansionist aims during this period. Understand the emergence of Japan as a modern nation-state during the Meiji era and its desire to become a world power.
2. Analyze Japan's motives: Discuss why Japan wanted to control its neighbors, particularly Korea and China. One significant aspect to consider is the need for land and resources. As an island country, Japan faced limitations in terms of available resources, which led to a dependency on external sources. This drove Japan to acquire territories with abundant resources, like Korea and parts of China.
3. Explore Japan's imperialistic mindset: Discuss the broader context of imperialism and how it shaped Japan's actions. Imperialism, characterized by a desire for economic and territorial control, was a common motive for many countries during that era. Japan, like other imperialist powers, aimed to establish colonies to secure a reliable supply of raw materials for its industries.
4. Consider geopolitical factors: Examine the geopolitical objectives underlying Japan's expansionism. For example, control over Korea and parts of China allowed Japan to establish a buffer zone against potential threats, expand its influence in the region, and strengthen its position as a military power.
5. Discuss the consequences: Examine the impact of Japan's control over neighboring territories. This could include the exploitation of resources, forced assimilation, suppression of local cultures and languages, and conflicts that arose as a result of Japan's expansionist policies.
Remember to cite credible sources and provide evidence to support your arguments while discussing this topic. Engage in a respectful and nuanced conversation, considering both the motivations behind Japan's actions and the complexities of the historical context.