The styles of singing in Wagner and Verdi operas differ. Jane
says that the style of singing in a Verdi opera is virtuosic and
elaborate. Lynn says that the style of singing in a Wagner opera
is more syllabic. Who is correct in describing the different
styles of singing?
A. Only Jane is correct
B.Only Lynn is correct
C.Neither Jane nor Lynn is correct.
Here is the definition of elaborate and virtuosic: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SWAQvpPDTuU&feature=related
Here is the definition of syllabic. Little to no ornamentation.
(Broken Link Removed)
Maria Callas was truly great, she took the Met stage in the 50-60s by storm, and deserved was recognized. I am glad that I experience her in my lifetime.
Listen to the entirety of both those tracks, no just a snippet.
In my opinion, and you form your own, both are correct.
not 100% sure, but i feel like both maybe correct?
To determine who is correct in describing the different styles of singing in Wagner and Verdi operas, we need to understand the characteristics of each composer's music.
Verdi, an Italian composer, is known for his expressive and melodic style. His operas often feature arias that showcase the virtuosic abilities of the singers. This means that the vocal lines are highly ornamented and intricate, requiring a skilled and agile voice to perform them effectively. Therefore, Jane is correct in stating that the style of singing in a Verdi opera is virtuosic and elaborate.
On the other hand, Wagner, a German composer, had a different approach to opera. He is recognized for his concept of "Gesamtkunstwerk" or "total artwork," where all elements of the opera, including music, libretto, and stage design, work together harmoniously. In Wagner's operas, the emphasis is more on the overall dramatic effect rather than showcasing the virtuosity of individual singers. The vocal lines in Wagner's operas tend to be more syllabic, meaning that each syllable of the text is set to a separate note. This allows for clear and dramatic storytelling instead of intricate melodic ornamentation. Thus, Lynn is correct in stating that the style of singing in a Wagner opera is more syllabic.
Based on this analysis, we can conclude that both Jane and Lynn are correct in their descriptions of the different styles of singing in Wagner and Verdi operas. Therefore, the correct answer is C. Neither Jane nor Lynn is incorrect.