poetry

posted by .

A man of such obvious and exemplary charm must be a liar - Brookner


ONE SAYS:

This is not a causal statement yet it is written so. "If it is raining, then there must be water" is a good use of the word must. Brookner should have chosen "likely" or "most probably."

Witty response: the root of charm is compliment. A "liar" does not speak truthfully. Perhaps then the object of focus is not worth the compliment/charm- then it would be a lie.

I SAY: i simply think Brookner meant that guys who try too hard make it obvious that they are trying to only impress ! So not only is he lying to himself of what he is trying to present but also lying to his audience

whos right in this one ?

  • poetry -

    I think "ONE SAYS: ... " is correct. I understand what you are saying, and poetically your interpretation is a good one. However, does Brookner mean that every single man with "obvious and exemplary charm" is a liar??

Respond to this Question

First Name
School Subject
Your Answer

Similar Questions

  1. Question For GuruBlue

    When you told me to write: Time is the ally of truth, or the worst enemy of a liar, and revenge is having the truth presented to public and the liar made obvious. Are any of these quotes?
  2. math

    can someone correct this for me... solve: -4(2x - 3) = -8x + 5 my answer: this equation has no solution because they don't equal i get 0=-7 -4(2x-3)=-8x+5 -8x+12=-8x+5 0(x)=-7 So am I correct You are right, let me explain a bit more. …
  3. Logic

    This exercise relate to the inhabitants of the island of knights and knaves created by Smullyan, where knights always tell the truth and knaves always lie. You encounter two people, A and B. Determine, if possible, what A and B are …
  4. Math

    There are two kinds of people live in the country of King Arthur: those who always say the truth and those who always lie. One day the king ordered that all the liars must be put in jail. A woman, whose husband was put in jail, went …
  5. English

    I don't know how to start the rephrase of Chapter 1 of Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice. Can you please have a look at it?
  6. Biology

    There is probably a really obvious answer to this but could you help please?
  7. Geometry

    Assume the following is a true statement. If it is raining, I will carry an umbrella. Which form of the original statement must also be true?
  8. English

    1. That's fine with me. (Does 'with' mean 'being related to'?
  9. Philosophy

    1. For each of the following underlined statements identify any vagueness, semantic ambiguity or syntactic ambiguity in the statement. If the statement is vague, explain why. If the statement is ambiguous, provide at least two alternative …
  10. English

    1. They had a telling-a-lie contest in the palace. Many people gathered in the palace.One man stepped up to the king and said,.... [Can we use the expression in the first sentence?

More Similar Questions